Publish date:

MLS Power Rankings Week 1: Piatti, Magee thrive on opening day

Ignacio Piatti, Sebastian Giovinco and Mike Magee stood out in a high-scoring MLS Week 1, writes Liviu Bird in his Power Rankings.

The first stages of Major League Soccer seasons normally look sloppy, and many of Sunday’s opening-day matches fit that bill. Defenses are far from familiar in Week 1 despite going through preseason together, and attackers can usually take advantage to the tune of multiple goals per game.

Certainly, neither the New England Revolution nor the Houston Dynamo defended well in their first match of the season. It finished 3-3, with 27 shots between the two teams flying toward goal in a game with multiple errors on the back end.

Indeed, only four teams failed to score on Sunday, and just two of 10 games finished with a solitary goal. New York City FC turned in a crazy 4-3 win over the Chicago Fire, in which NYCFC was the only team to lead in the match to give Patrick Vieira a victory in his MLS coaching debut.

Sebastian Giovinco, the reigning league MVP, kick-started his season by orchestrating a 2-0 win for Toronto FC over the Supporters’ Shield-holding New York Red Bulls. In keeping with the theme, he also pantomimed kick-starting a motorcycle in his goalscoring celebration after he put away the 82nd-minute penalty that would prove to be the winner.

Toronto's was as close to a statement of intent that you can get on opening day in MLS, one coming from a team that has made a lot of noise without really winning anything in its history. However, its Canadian neighbor Montreal Impact made a statement of their own in a 3-2 win over the Vancouver Whitecaps, with Ignacio Piatti stepping up big in Didier Drogba’s turf-induced absence.

In another wild, multi-goal game, Orlando City SC scored in the 94th and 95th minutes after going down 2-0 to Real Salt Lake to earn a point. It was a rough game, with both teams going down to 10 men before halftime.

The 2016 MLS Ambition Rankings

The best teams from the Western Conference in 2015 continued their winning ways, with FC Dallas taking probably the most comfortable victory of the week in a 2-0 match against the Philadelphia Union. The Portland Timbers, meanwhile, won their MLS Cup rematch against the Columbus Crew, 2-1, despite Federico Higuaín’s acrobatic overhead kick that equalized the match for 11 minutes in the second half.

The San Jose Earthquakes and Sporting Kansas City turned in the only 1-0 results of the week, defeating the Colorado Rapids and Seattle Sounders, respectively. Finally, to cap a long day of MLS play, the LA Galaxy came from behind to defeat D.C. United, 4-1, despite losing new starting goalkeeper Dan Kennedy to a first-half injury. Mike Magee thrived in his return to the Galaxy, coming off the bench at halftime and contributing two goals and an assist in addition to drawing a penalty.

Here are some highlights from the kickoff to MLS’s third decade of play:

Coach’s Corner: Breaching Seattle’s three-headed monster

The Sounders’ new 4-3-3 look has been built up all offseason, created in an effort to get all of their attacking pieces on the field at the same time. Even with the loss of Obafemi Martins to China, coach Sigi Schmid stuck with the system against Kansas City.

It featured three narrow forwards in the attack, as the trio of Clint Dempsey, Nelson Valdez and Jordan Morris doesn’t contain a true winger. That put a lot more pressure on the fullbacks, Joevin Jones and Oniel Fisher on Sunday, to provide width moving forward.

In turn, that created tricky situations in transition moments, particularly when Seattle lost the ball in the initial phases of build-up. In the 21st minute, Dom Dwyer picked off a ball in the top half and had a huge gap to slip the ball to Connor Hallisey, but goalkeeper Stefan Frei came up with the save.


A moment like this is also what led to Fisher’s sending off just before halftime, as he scrambled back into a reckless tackle in transition, completely changing the complexion of the game. Fisher’s speed makes him a flashy player, but much like DeAndreYedlin in the same position before him, he’ll need to balance that better with his defensive responsibilities.

Relying on recovery speed could leave his team in trouble in those moments all season, as opponents could target that space the fullbacks leave behind when they move forward. Kansas City, whether consciously or not, sent many of their outlet passes in the back and middle thirds into those wider areas.


With the important role he played defensively as usual, it’s hard to believe Osvaldo Alonso looked like he was on his way out of the Emerald City not too long ago. He recovered 11 loose balls, made one interception and went 59-for-63 in pass attempts for a 93.7% success rate, continuing to be the Sounders’ steadiest presence in their MLS era.

The SI Extra Newsletter Get the best of Sports Illustrated delivered right to your inbox


Attacking Player of the Week: Ignacio Piatti, Montreal Impact

With 36 goals across the 10 matches on Sunday came several multiple point-getters, but Piatti’s performance stood out above the rest for what it might symbolize. Drogba won’t play four of the first five games in the Impact’s season because they’re on turf, and the team struggled in the attack in 2015 before he joined in late summer.

The pieces on this Montreal team in 2016, though, could reverse that trend. Of course, Drogba’s goal-per-game scoring rate will be welcome once he gets back into a rhythm, but two goals and an assist from Piatti make him a viable shadow man.

Behind the MLS Ambition Rankings: Inside info on each team

The Impact needed every one of his contributions, too, as he had a hand in every goal in a victory by a one-score margin.

Giovinco is the runner-up in this competition, scoring the winner and assisting the second in Toronto’s 2-0 win. TFC’s attack got off 12 shots and hit the target five times, but it wasn’t until Giovinco conjured two key moments in the last 10 minutes against the Red Bulls that the Reds finally scored.

Others with impressive first-week performances included Magee’s uplifting performance off the bench for the Galaxy; Joao Plata, who scored both of RSL’s goals and would probably be higher on the list had his team pulled out the win; and Diego Fagúndez, with his goal and two assists for New England in Houston. Finally, Mauro Díaz assisted on both goals in Dallas’ win over Philadelphia.

Defensive Player of the Week: Evan Bush, Montreal Impact

This was a tough decision between two good goalkeeping performances, but Piatti’s teammate on the opposite end takes the honors for his multiple big saves for the Impact. André Blake, perhaps finally set to get a run of games as the Union’s starter, also showed well but looked a little slow off his line on the opening goal of the 2-0 loss to Dallas.


The goalkeepers in general had a lot to do with the Week 1-quality defenses in front of them, and Bush and Blake certainly had plenty of opportunities to shine. They both ended up with eight saves in their respective games.

The variety of Bush’s interventions helped his cause, as he stopped a 1-on-1 early, made a diving reaction save late on to keep the lead and stopped plenty of shots in between. He couldn’t do much about two point-blank chances on set pieces, but he could hardly be faulted, either.

David Bingham also held together the Earthquakes’ victory with several stops, but he looked a little less clean technically than Bush. Bingham can take some solace from the fact that he did keep the shutout, continuing a positive 2016 so far in which he also made his debut for the U.S. men's national team.

Further honorable mentions go to FC Dallas center back Walker Zimmerman and Earthquakes defender Víctor Bernárdez for their roles in their teams’ shutouts. Goal-scoring defenders Kendall Waston and Nuno Coelho impressed on the other end of the field.

Image placeholder title

1. FC Dallas


RECORD: 1-0-0

Óscar Pareja’s men didn’t struggle much to put away Philadelphia, taking a 2-0 win that could have been a lot more lopsided if not for some goalkeeping heroics, but losing Fabián Castillo late could be a big blow.

Image placeholder title

2. Portland Timbers


RECORD: 1-0-0

Despite giving up an acrobatic equalizer to Federico Higuain, Portland pulled out a 2-1 victory over Columbus with an unusual deficit of possession at home, showing that winning games doesn’t always mean having more of the ball.

Image placeholder title

3. Toronto FC


RECORD: 1-0-0

Sebastian Giovinco is back, although he and TFC only needed the last 10 minutes to defeat the Red Bulls, 2-0, on opening day behind a penalty and stoppage-time counterattack.

Image placeholder title

4. LA Galaxy


RECORD: 1-0-0

Perhaps the Galaxy’s goalkeeping headaches aren’t over, as Dan Kennedy came out injured a few minutes after giving up a soft goal in a 4-1 win over D.C. in which LA didn’t get going until the second half.

Image placeholder title

5. Montreal Impact


SI Recommends

RECORD: 1-0-0

Ignacio Piatti stepped up in a big way in Didier Drogba’s absence, having a hand in every goal the Impact scored in a 3-2 win in Vancouver and showing that this might not be just a one-man attack.

Image placeholder title

6. New York Red Bulls


RECORD: 0-1-0

More than 80 minutes of dominance, to the tune of 63% possession, ultimately meant nothing for the Red Bulls as they lost to two late Toronto goals.

Image placeholder title

7. Sporting Kansas City


RECORD: 1-0-0

Ironically, Coelho didn’t even look like he wanted the ball just moments before his long-range shot squeaked into the net to give Sporting a 1-0 road win in Seattle on opening day.

Image placeholder title

8. Columbus Crew SC


RECORD: 0-1-0

Higuaín’s overhead kick will be up for Goal of the Week, but the Crew will be disappointed it couldn’t do better than a 2-1 loss at Providence Park despite having more than 60% possession.

Image placeholder title

9. New York City FC


RECORD: 1-0-0

It was pretty sloppy, and you’d expect a team coached by Patrick Vieira to defend better than it did in Chicago, but a 4-3 win in the Frenchman’s first match in charge is all that mattered.

Image placeholder title

10. San Jose Earthquakes


RECORD: 1-0-0

In a game featuring the Earthquakes’ trademark direct play, Chris Wondolowski scored just moments into the second half to lift San Jose over Colorado by a solitary goal.

Image placeholder title

11. Vancouver Whitecaps


RECORD: 0-1-0

In a 3-2 loss to Montréal, familiar issues resurfaced for the Whitecaps, who dropped 22 points at home in 2015, as Carl Robinson’s team continues to look more comfortable playing on the counterattack than controlling play.

Image placeholder title

12. Seattle Sounders


RECORD: 0-1-0

Oniel Fisher’s straight red card just before halftime killed the Sounders’ chances in a 1-0 loss to Sporting Kansas City, as Seattle conceded much of the control it had on the game with its full complement on the field.

Image placeholder title

13. New England Revolution


RECORD: 0-0-1

It’s been a couple years since Diego Fagúndez’s 13-goal 2013 season marked him as a player to watch, but the Uruguayan showed that he’s still more than capable, scoring once and assisting twice in a comeback draw in Houston.

Image placeholder title

14. Houston Dynamo


RECORD: 0-0-1

Even without Cubo Torres, Houston looked more exciting in attack than it did in 2015, playing to a six-goal draw against New England; now, the focus has to be shoring up the back line.

Image placeholder title

15. Real Salt Lake


RECORD: 0-0-1

Not injured from the start of the season this time, Plata made good on his clean health with a goal on either side of halftime, but RSL collapsed late to lose two points on the road to Orlando.

Image placeholder title

16. Orlando City SC


RECORD: 0-0-1

The Lions put together a wicked comeback in front of over 60,000 at the Citrus Bowl, scoring twice in stoppage time to tie RSL, in a reversal of late-game fortune from 2015, when Orlando came out on the wrong end of a series of late-game decisions.

Image placeholder title

17. Chicago Fire


RECORD: 0-1-0

After an undefeated preseason, Chicago got nothing out of its first regular-season game, a 4-3 loss to NYCFC that marked the first time the Fire didn’t have complete control under Veljko Paunović.

Image placeholder title

18. D.C. United


RECORD: 0-1-0

After going up 1-0 early in LA, it was a classic defensive D.C. performance, falling back in the face of the Galaxy’s advantage in possession and shots before eventually seeing its advantage turned into a 4-1 loss.

Image placeholder title

19. Colorado Rapids


RECORD: 0-1-0

Colorado got off 18 shots and kept nearly 60% possession against San Jose but, mirroring a 2015 in which the Rapids were MLS’s lowest-scoring team, couldn’t put any in the back of the net in a 1-0 loss.

Image placeholder title

20. Philadelphia Union


RECORD: 0-1-0

Without Maurice Edu and Tranquillo Barnetta in the lineup due to their respective injuries, the Union didn’t make many strides forward from the way it finished last season in a 2-0 loss to Dallas.