Should MLS adopt instant replay?
4:51 | Planet Futbol
Should MLS adopt instant replay?
Monday March 14th, 2016

More late drama permeated Major League Soccer in the second week of the new season. Ten goals were scored in the 70th minute or later across the league’s 10 matches this weekend, including three game-winners.

After Orlando City SC’s two-goal stoppage-time comeback in Week 1, recent Colorado Rapids acquisition Marco Pappa stunned the LA Galaxy with a 95th-minute winner on Saturday. The Rapids’ 1-0 win over LA clearly delighted struggling coach Pablo Mastroeni, who ripped off his suit jacket and threw it to the ground in celebration on the bench.

The team on the other end of Orlando’s comeback, Real Salt Lake, put away a late result of its own against the Seattle Sounders. In his team’s home opener, Jámison Olave scored on an 86th-minute header to give RSL a 2-1 comeback win.

The Montreal Impact and Houston Dynamo had no such trouble in their matches, defeating the New York Red Bulls 3-0 and FC Dallas 5-0, respectively. The Red Bulls’ Supporters’ Shield defense is off to a shaky start following two losses to open the season, and reigning top Western Conference seed Dallas fell apart after a solid win of its own last week.

Jordan Smith of the Vancouver Whitecaps and the Chicago Fire’s Michael Harrington both earned the week’s only red cards for poor first-half tackles. Vancouver lost again, 2-1 to Sporting Kansas City, as Dom Dwyer got off the mark with a couple good finishes before Smith’s sending-off, while Chicago managed to hold Orlando to a 1-1 draw after neither team could score following the incident.

Meanwhile, the New England Revolution and D.C. United gave the league its first scoreless draw of the season, though the Revs heavily out-shot and out-possessed D.C. on Saturday. The next day, New York City FC took a 2-0 lead over Toronto FC in the first half but couldn’t hold it, as TFC came back for a 2-2 draw at Yankee Stadium.

Capping off a week that included some bizarre results, the San Jose Earthquakes were up 2-0 on the Portland Timbers until Jack McInerney’s consolation goal with one minute left.

It finished 2-1 in San Jose’s favor, even though the Earthquakes left two Designated Players, Innocent Emeghara and Matías Pérez García, on the bench the whole game.

Read on for some more highlights from Week 2 of the MLS season:

Coach’s Corner: Chicago tactical flexibility

In his short time as Chicago manager, Veljko Paunović has instilled a sense of belief and a new tactical understanding that led to an undefeated preseason. The Fire has just one point from two games so far in the regular season, but the flexibility it has shown in the past couple months could be important later in the season.

As teams shift players around to account for injuries, international duty and loss of form, being able to play more than one system becomes more important. Chicago has moved between a 4-2-3-1 and 5-3-2 already so far, depending on the opponent, location and game situation.

Planet Futbol
Paunovic brings unique experience, style to Chicago Fire's reboot

The Fire started Week 1 against NYCFC with a four-back arrangement. Chicago couldn’t take as many liberties moving forward, though, or risk getting too stretched in transition moments as NYCFC won the ball.

The central midfielders had to split farther apart to compensate and fill spaces defensively, leaving a gap ahead of the back line and central defenders with a dilemma about how to support if a runner checked off the front line.

NYCFC’s three central-most players, David Villa, Mix Diskerud and Thomas McNamara, overloaded the channel against fewer numbers due to the lack of compactness.

Chicago moved to five backs in the second half against NYCFC and started that way against Orlando on Saturday, until Harrington was sent off. With three central defenders, the Fire had easier cover built into the team’s starting shape.

If a forward checked back, a central defender could follow him without giving up as much in behind, as the other two could slide over to cover much easier, and the near-side wingback could tuck in. It allowed the central midfielders more freedom in attack, while also compensating for the lack of team compactness while they recovered toward their own goal.

The resulting influence on the opposition across the two weeks showed why NYCFC created five chances in the central zone on top of the penalty area in the first half, while Orlando mustered two. With easier access to that area (“Zone 14” in tactical parlance), 13.9% of NYCFC’s actions occurred there, while just 7.4% of Orlando’s did.

Chicago pushed Orlando wider, forcing lower-percentage passes in most situations. It’s impossible to tell what would have happened over the balance of 90 minutes without the red card, but look for Chicago to switch between its two systems as games dictate, depending on the opponent’s strengths and whether the Fire has more or less of the game or a lead to protect.

The SI Extra Newsletter Get the best of Sports Illustrated delivered right to your inbox

Attacking Player of the Week: Andrew Wenger, Houston Dynamo

It’s been a long road for Wenger, the first pick in the 2012 MLS SuperDraft. Recently traded to the Dynamo after bouncing from Montreal to Philadelphia, he hasn’t made as much of an impact on the pro level as he did in a stellar college career.

Saturday, he put up just the third multi-point game of his MLS tenure, assisting twice and scoring once in a blowout against Dallas. His goal put a cap on an outrageous first half-hour, in which the Dynamo went up 4-0.

Planet Futbol
MLS teams still unable to solve CONCACAF Champions League

Wenger dipped a pinpoint cross between two defenders and onto David Horst’s head in the sixth minute for Houston’s first goal, followed by a smart cutback cross into Ricardo Clark’s path at the top of the penalty area in the 23rd.

Finally, he made an incisive third-man run from the right wing and got a fortuitous bounce off two defenders to score in the 27th.

He might have needed a touch of luck to get the goal, but it was a just reward for his service on the first two and potentially what Wenger needed to kick-start a breakout season in MLS.

Two-goal scorers Chris Pontius, also making a new start with the Union; Dom Dwyer and David Villa receive honorable mentions this week. Dwyer’s first goal, a long-distance bomb from outside the penalty area on a one-man counterattack, would have been the easy pick for Goal of the Week if not for Quincy Amarikwa's long-range chip that will be one of the best of the entire season. Sebastian Giovinco also scored one and assisted the other for Toronto.

Defensive Player of the Week: Andre Blake, Philadelphia Union

Given the No. 1 jersey at the start of the season, Blake has turned in two more than solid performances for Philadelphia in between the sticks to begin 2016. The Jamaican international finished with six saves on Saturday against the Crew, only conceding a consolation goal with just a couple minutes to go.

Planet Futbol
Behind the MLS Ambition Rankings: Inside info on each team

He’s shown impressive range in his shot-stopping ability already. Late in the first half, he pushed a close-range shot beyond the far post from low to his left, getting down into an area that taller goalkeepers generally struggle to protect.

He also made saves higher to both sides late in the game, though he couldn’t keep out Kei Kamara’s upper-corner header from a corner kick.

Like Wenger, Blake was also a first overall pick in the draft (2014) and the first goalkeeper to be selected first. After the revolving door of gloved guardians that was the Union goal in the last couple years, the coaching staff seems to finally have settled on the solution that was obvious to many on the outside.

Marcelo Sarvas, now of D.C., and the three players tasked with defending centrally for the Impact, Calum Mallace in midfield and Víctor Cabrera and Laurent Ciman in central defense, receive honorable mentions. Sarvas ran the D.C. attack with his distribution, also putting in five successful tackles, five interceptions and six loose-ball recoveries in a scoreless draw.

Cabrera, Ciman and Mallace collectively ensured Montreal’s shutout of the Red Bulls, protecting their own goal brilliantly while also distributing well. It’s hard to separate the three performances in terms of their level and importance to the team, but the three men combined for 21 recoveries, 12 clearances, 16 interceptions, 12 tackles won and only one lost.

MLS Power Rankings, Week 2
  • 1
    1Montreal Impact
    last week: 5
    record: 2-0-0
    Ignacio Piatti scored again, and the Impact continued their attacking tear without Didier Drogba in the lineup in its 3-0 defeat of the Red Bulls.

  • 2
    2Sporting Kansas City
    last week: 7
    record: 2-0-0
    A double from Dom Dwyer, including a thunderous opening goal, carried Kansas City to its second win in a row with a 2-1 result against Vancouver.

  • 3
    3Portland Timbers
    last week: 2
    record: 1-1-0
    The defending champion took a tumble in San Jose despite getting 16 shots to the Earthquakes’ eight and attempting 28 crosses to eight; the trouble was Portland only got two shots on target and only connected on five crosses.

  • 4
    4Toronto FC
    last week: 3
    record: 1-0-1
    Sebastian Giovinco engineered a comeback for TFC at Yankee Stadium on Sunday, assisting on a goal in first-half stoppage time before scoring one in the 76th minute to claw back a 2-2 away draw.

  • 5
    5FC Dallas
    last week: 1
    record: 1-1-0
    Dallas crashed after a strong start in Week 1, with a shocking 5-0 loss to Houston, prompting early questions about the team’s consistency—something that had been an issue in recent years but looked to be rectified last year.

  • 6
    6San Jose Earthquakes
    last week: 10
    record: 2-0-0
    San Jose jumped to a two-goal lead in the first half against the Timbers–punctuated by Quincy Amarikwa's stunner–only conceding a late consolation marker on the way to tying Sporting Kansas City for a very early lead atop the Western Conference.

  • 7
    7LA Galaxy
    last week: 4
    record: 1-1-0
    The Galaxy struggled to get their attack going after a second-half outburst in the first week, falling to a Rapids goal from Marco Pappa deep into stoppage time.

  • 8
    8Houston Dynamo
    last week: 14
    record: 1-0-1
    The Dynamo are MLS’s highest-scoring team after two games following an explosive 5-0 win over rival FC Dallas on Saturday in which Houston led by four inside the first half hour.

  • 9
    9New York Red Bulls
    last week: 6
    record: 0-2-0
    Two weeks, five goals conceded, zero scored and two disappointing losses—the Red Bulls are off to a shaky start after their 2015 Supporters’ Shield-winning season.

  • 10
    10New York City FC
    last week: 9
    record: 1-0-1
    David Villa scored twice in the first half hour, but NYCFC couldn’t make a two-goal lead stick for a victory; Patrick Vieira’s team also trotted out a 3-4-1-2 lineup not frequently seen in MLS.

  • 11
    11Columbus Crew SC
    last week: 8
    record: 0-2-0
    For the second week in a row, Columbus kept 60% possession, adding 19 total shots against Philadelphia but managing to lose by the same 2-1 scoreline as it did the first game.

  • 12
    12Vancouver Whitecaps
    last week: 11
    record: 0-2-0
    Jordan Smith’s red card in first-half stoppage time capped a frustrating half that sank the Whitecaps in Kansas City; Vancouver looked much better in the second half, though, scoring its goal in the 2-1 loss.

  • 13
    13Seattle Sounders
    last week: 12
    record: 0-2-0
    After a loss in the waning minutes to RSL, the Sounders are still without a win in four matches in 2016 after a draw and loss in the CONCACAF Champions League and a Week 1 loss to Sporting KC.

  • 14
    14Real Salt Lake
    last week: 15
    record: 1-0-1
    After being on the wrong end of a stunning two-goal comeback to drop two points on the road last week, RSL scored the winning goal against Seattle in the 86th minute to win its home opener on Saturday.

  • 15
    15New England Revolution
    last week: 13
    record: 0-0-2
    The Revs’ shot chart from Saturday is an absolute mess, with lines crisscrossing the goal from every direction, but New England only hit the target three times (once from inside the penalty area) in a goalless draw with D.C.

  • 16
    16Philadelphia Union
    last week: 20
    record: 1-1-0
    New acquisition Chris Pontius came up with two goals, and Andre Blake was again huge on the other end as the Union won in Columbus for the first time in franchise history, 2-1.

  • 17
    17Orlando City SC
    last week: 16
    record: 0-0-2
    Cyle Larin scored in the first five minutes and should have also won a penalty in stoppage time, but referee Ted Unkel didn’t blow his whistle, and Orlando finished with its second draw in two weeks.

  • 18
    18Colorado Rapids
    last week: 19
    record: 1-1-0
    Sometimes, teams in scoring slumps need something emphatic to break their slump, and that’s what Colorado got from second-half substitute Pappa’s late volley to beat LA 1-0 on Saturday.

  • 19
    19Chicago Fire
    last week: 17
    record: 0-1-1
    A fairly early red card for Michael Harrington doomed the Fire to playing with 10 for nearly an hour away from home against Orlando, but Chicago still managed to grind out its first point under Veljko Paunović.

  • 20
    20D.C. United
    last week: 18
    record: 0-1-1
    United’s attack will be a big question mark this year, as the team didn’t get any clear looks at goal despite eight shots and three on target at New England, leading to a goalless draw.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.