College Football Playoff Selection Committee’s First Rankings: Three Things We Learned From New Top 25

In this story:
The day has arrived. As millions of Americans around the country cast their votes at the ballot box, so too did the College Football Playoff selection committee, unveiling the season’s first CFP Top 25 on Tuesday night.
This season has been a true roller coaster, featuring upsets, hangover game losses and a constant shuffling of teams believed to be in the playoff mix. Four different teams have occupied the No. 1 spot in the AP Top 25, for example, and 12 different programs have received first-place votes.
There are just three remaining undefeated teams in all of FBS, and just one from the “Power 2” conferences ... a stunning 8–0 UCLA club under first-year coach Bob Chesney. The Bruins are joined by Miami and Utah, two of the presumptive top four seeds in tonight’s rankings.
While there is still plenty of football to be played before the final 12-team bracket is announced on Sunday, December 6, we learned plenty about how this selection committee is weighing things so far:
The Jordan Travis rule is still a thing
Never forget Mike Norvell’s 13–0, ACC-champion Florida State team from 2023, which lost starting quarterback and Heisman Trophy candidate Jordan Travis to a season-ending injury and then was snubbed from the four-team College Football Playoff despite winning its remaining regular season games.
That year, the selection committee made it clear that they simply didn’t view the Seminoles as worthy of the CFP with a backup quarterback. And while new committee members have rotated in and the Playoff has expanded to 12 teams—and counting—the decision-makers made clear on Tuesday night that the Travis rule is still a thing.

While the case of backup-itis could be made for the committee’s rankings of UCLA and Boise State, there was no better example of the Travis rule than Ohio State falling to 12th, just outside the CFP given the highest ranked Group of 6 team’s autobid.
The Buckeyes lost 2025 Heisman Trophy finalist Julian Sayin to injury in its win over Indiana on Oct. 17, and the offense promptly went nowhere down the stretch of that narrow victory. Then, after having a bye week to get backup Luke Fahey up to speed, Ryan Day’s squad fell flat against a very beatable USC defense.
It’s understandable that the Buckeyes were going to drop a few spots, but all the way down to 12th feels like a slight overreaction, given Day’s track record and the talent on the roster. Committee chair Hunter Yurachek played verbal gymnastics in explaining the ranking: “Ohio State is not being penalized for having a quarterback that’s out there, they’re being evaluated as a team with another quarterback in the lineup for them.” But it’s likely that a Sayin-led team, even if it had stumbled against USC, would have garnered more respect.
And in dropping Ohio State, the committee made one thing clear. If you lose your starting QB to injury, beware.
Head-to-head mattered—until it didn’t
The second criterion the committee uses to evaluate résumés of CFP contenders is head-to-head results. And throughout the rankings, there is evidence of that being the case. Oregon over Boise State. Texas Tech over Houston. Ole Miss over LSU.
And then there were instances where it looked like the committee played one giant game of Twister while trying to pigeonhole head-to-head outcomes into the rankings. The result? Instances where it sort of mattered and others where it didn’t at all. Alabama checked in at fifth over Kentucky, whom it defeated by 28 points back in September. Cool. But then the Crimson Tide are eight spots ahead of Tennessee, who rolled the Tide by 16 points in October. Huh?
And that wasn’t the only questionable instance. The committee worked to get Texas ahead of Ohio State to reflect the Longhorns’ biggest win of the season—and perhaps the Buckeyes’ compromised QB situation. But such a decision completely ignored Ohio State’s win over Indiana, with the Hoosiers checking in eight spots ahead of the Buckeyes.
Look, the committee has a thankless job here. There are going to be complaints no matter what rankings they dole out. But when they cling to their criteria like a life raft only to then ditch them as if they grew teeth, it raises serious credibility questions, and makes fans and pundits wonder just how much the stated criteria play in the process.
The hypocrisy of the signature win
Throughout the CFP rankings show, you heard the phrases “head-to-head” and “strength of schedule,” both key pieces of criteria in the selection committee’s process. But another phrase seeped into the analysis, and no one wielded the verbal sword more than Yurachek, who, while discussing Notre Dame’s low ranking at No. 11, stated that the Fighting Irish “don’t have that signature win right now.”
While we feel that’s a bit of an unfair ranking for the Irish, let’s accept that logic in a vacuum for a moment. Notre Dame doesn’t have a signature win and is ranked 11th. But where’s Indiana’s signature win? The Hoosiers, ranked fourth, have victories over a solid North Texas squad, middling Howard and Western Kentucky programs, capable Big Ten rivals in Northwestern and Nebraska, a Big Ten bottom feeder in Rutgers, a questionable Michigan team and a spunky Minnesota squad. Solid wins? Sure. But signature? I don’t see it.

The Hoosiers, beating teams by an average of 15.6 points, have looked impressive at times but have won by the skin of their teeth most of the time—four wins by a touchdown or fewer. Meanwhile, Notre Dame, outside of some sluggish first halves, has blown out its opponents by nearly four scores.
The committee twisted itself into a pretzel on Tuesday night in many ways, but the so-called signature win was among the most head-scratching forms of rankings gymnastics. —Tim Capurso
Miss the selection show? Keep scrolling for our live updates and takeaways, as well the full Top 25 rankings.
Live updates, analysis, reaction to the season’s first College Football Playoff Top 25
College Football Playoff selection committee Top 25
1. Miami (8–0)
2. Georgia (7–1)
3. Utah (8–0)
4. Indiana (8–1)
5. Alabama (6–2)
6. Kentucky (7–1)
7. Texas (7–2)
8. UCLA (8–0)
9. BYU (7–1)
10. Ole Miss (6–2)
11. Notre Dame (7–1)
12. Ohio State (6–2)
13. Tennessee (6–2)
14. LSU (6–2)
15. Texas Tech (7–1)
16. Wake Forest (7–1)
17. Houston (6–2)
18. Missouri (6–2)
19. Iowa (6–2)
20. USC (7–2)
21. South Carolina (5–3)
22. Arizona (6–2)
23. Oregon (5–3)
24. Florida (5–3)
25. Boise State (7–1)
How the 12-team playoff field is determined
Each year of the 12-team College Football Playoff (which expanded from four teams in 2024) has featured slight tweaks. This year’s field will feature:
- The conference champions from the Power 4 conferences (ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, SEC) as automatic bids.
- The highest-ranked Group of 6 (American, Conference USA, MAC, Mountain West, Pac-12, Sun Belt) program, regardless of conference champion status.
- Seven at-large programs.
- Notre Dame receives an automatic bid if it finishes within the top 12 of the final rankings.
The top four teams in the field receive byes, regardless of conference champion status.
CFP selection committee members
- Hunter Yurachek, Arkansas athletic director (committee chair)
- Troy Dannen, Nebraska athletic director
- Mark Dantonio, former Michigan State, Cincinnati coach
- Doug Gillin, Appalachian State athletic director
- Mark Harlan, Utah athletic director
- Ivan Maisel, former sports writer at SI, ESPN, other outlets
- Gus Malzahn, former Auburn, UCF, Arkansas State coach
- Chris Massaro, Middle Tennessee State athletic director
- Randall McDaniel, former Arizona State All-American offensive lineman
- Mike Riley, former Oregon State, Nebraska coach
- Jeff Tedford, former Cal, Fresno State coach
- Wesley Walls, former Mississippi All-American tight end
- Carla Williams, Virginia athletic director
The members recuse themselves from discussion when they have any conflict with a school being discussed, and are barred from voting on those programs.
PODCAST: Listen to Sports Illustrated’s college sports podcast, Others Receiving Votes, hosted by Pat Forde, on Apple and Spotify. Watch the show on SI’s college YouTube channel or on SI TV.

Brian Giuffra is the VP of Betting Content at Minute Media and has been with the company since 2016. He's a fan of the Knicks, Giants, wine and bourbon, usually consuming them in that order.
Follow brian_giuffra