Meyer beats out Saban for top spot in SEC coaching rankings

Publish date:

With the dust settled on the head coaching searches across the nation, it's prime time to rank the coaches in each BCS conference.

This is a highly subjective exercise I've attempted annually for the past three years, and my main criteria is a mix of future projections and past performances.

First up, the SEC, which will now and forever be the premier conference in America. It's also a league that experienced as much coaching tumult as any, with three new coaches -- Tennessee's Lane Kiffin, Auburn's Gene Chizik and Mississippi State's Dan Mullen -- joining the ranks.

Meyer's coming off his second BCS title in three seasons. Add in a 12-0 season at Utah in 2004, and Meyer is the closest thing to college football perfection walking the gridiron. He boasts an 83-17 career record, and he's only 44-years-old. Are you thinking what I'm thinking? You know, what more can Meyer accomplish at the college level? The pull of the NFL will become too strong at some point for college football's prince.

Two seasons into his tenure, it looks like Saban may be underpaid at $4 million per season. Last season was a breakthrough of monumental proportions that few could have anticipated, with Saban leading the Tide to a 12-2 record. As he continues to hoard talent, it's only a matter of time before Saban wins his second BCS title. How much fun will it be to watch Saban battle Meyer for SEC supremacy in coming years?

Here's food for thought: Is Richt losing some of his luster? He had what many felt was the nation's No. 1 team last season, but the Bulldogs ended up in the Capital One Bowl. No doubt, Richt has achieved a lot, going 82-22 in eight seasons in Athens. And he is a survivor; he's the longest-tenured coach in the SEC. But programs blessed with this many bells and whistles are measured by championships, and Richt hasn't won the SEC title since 2005 and has never won a national title.

He was never appreciated at Arkansas, where he led a school that never teems with blue-chip talent to three SEC title games and eight bowls in 10 seasons. In one season in Oxford, Nutt has already gained legions of believers following a 9-4 record and Cotton Bowl triumph over Texas Tech. Few motivate or scheme as well as Nutt.

Spurrier sealed his Hall-of-Fame status by laying the foundation for a dynasty at Florida that included six SEC titles and a national championship. But four mostly mediocre seasons (28-22) in Columbia have chipped away at that legacy. Spurrier can't seem to get the Gamecocks over the hump, which is maddening to the fat cats in those Cockabooses. He turns 64 in April.

It seems any currency Miles earned by leading LSU to the 2007 BCS title vanished with last season's 8-5 clunker that saw the Tigers go 3-5 in the SEC. Now, Miles seemingly has to prove himself all over again. And he'll do it with a rebuilt coaching staff. Talent is never an issue in Baton Rouge, but it's up to Miles to coach 'em up.

Brooks laid the foundation for a powerful program at Oregon from 1977-94. Now, he has made Kentucky a strong and respected program since taking command in 2003. The Wildcats have won three consecutive bowls for the first time in their history. Now, the question looms: When will Brooks -- who turns 68 in August -- hand off to coach-in-waiting Joker Phillips?

He might be a job hopper, but Petrino is also a fantastic play-caller and a terrific coach. He showed that during a great four-year run at Louisville, going 41-9 from 2003-06. Petrino offered a glimpse of the future when he rallied the Hogs to a 5-7 record in his debut season, highlighted by a season-ending 31-30 win over LSU. Stand back and watch the Hogs fly.

We dare you to find a coach who does more with less. You can't, so don't try. Johnson became a heroic figure when he delivered Vandy to its first bowl since 1982 last season after coming close in 2005 (5-6) and '07 (5-7). And if Johnson was ever going to get swooped up by a bigger school, it likely would have happened after last season. It didn't, so it looks like Johnson, 56, will likely finish his career in Music City. And that's a beautiful thing.

Can the guy coach? He went 5-19 in two seasons at Iowa State. Chizik supporters are quick to point out that hardly anyone wins in Ames. Regardless, the jury is out on Chizik. And going head-to-head with Alabama and Saban is no way for a neophyte coach to cut his teeth.

It hasn't taken Kiffin long to talk a good game. Will he be able to back it up? There's only one way to sum up his 5-15 stint as Oakland Raiders head coach: disastrous. Now Kiffin, 33, wades into one of the nation's most high-profile jobs in the most competitive conference in America. This can end two ways: 1. Kiffin will be a huge success; 2. Kiffin will be an utter disaster. There will be no in-between.

Let's go ahead and call him "Urban Junior" because that's who Mullen is. Pushing the buttons as the coordinator for a Florida offense that included Percy Harvin and Tim Tebow is one thing. Making Mississippi State's attack consistently functional is quite another. This is going to be fascinating to watch, and perhaps further proof that talent matters more than schemes. If Mullen, 36, can pull this off and make the Bulldogs a consistent bowl team, he will be hailed as a genius. And he also likely won't be in Starkville for long.