Arkansas, Wisconsin tumble out of Top 25 after being upset in Week 2

Arkansas, Wisconsin and Nebraska played their way out of one major poll but not the other. What does that mean? It means the sportswriters who vote in the AP Poll value current body of work far more than the sports information directors and operations guys who vote in the Coaches' Poll.
Arkansas has done nothing to deserve a ranking. The Razorbacks mucked around for a half in a win against Jacksonville State of the FCS and then mucked around for more than 60 minutes in an overtime loss to Louisiana-Monroe of the Sun Belt. Wisconsin? Similar story. The Badgers looked terrible against FCS opponent Northern Iowa and then laid an egg against Oregon State, which has been a Pac-12 doormat the past two seasons. Nebraska, meanwhile, looked pretty good against Southern Miss and then imploded at UCLA.
So why are those programs still ranked in the Coaches' Poll? Probably because coaches don't have to reveal their votes for most of the season. The information age has made it quite easy to access an AP voter's ballot. When we do something stupid -- me accidentally leaving off Ohio State last week, for example -- the people let us know. The coaches vote in the comfort of anonymity until the season's final week, when they vote pretty much strictly along conference lines. Unfortunately, the Coaches' Poll makes up a third of the BCS formula. This is yet another reason why the current system of choosing a national champion can't die soon enough. It's a shame we have to wait until 2014. (I don't say this because I think the AP Poll should be used to determine who plays for the national title. I don't want that evil on me. Reporters shouldn't be part of the story.)
While public pressure has forced the voters in the AP Poll to evolve, Coaches' Poll voters allow their preseason prejudices to influence in-season votes. There is nothing wrong with preseason polls -- which will never go away as long as obsessed readers click on them by the millions. The problem comes when a voter won't admit his preseason guess was wrong and drop a team based on that season's performance. If voters are willing to radically alter the rankings to reflect the action on the field, preseason rankings don't matter. They are nothing more than a summertime diversion designed to sate a football-starved populace.
One of the stupidest questions I get on a weekly basis from fans unhappy with the rankings is this: Well, what are you going to do if Team X beats Team Y? The answer is simple: I'm going to change the rankings. Will Arkansas, Wisconsin and Nebraska be ranked in the AP Poll at season's end? I have no idea. I imagine at least one or two will crack the top 25 again -- if they earn it. For instance, if the prediction of this Arkansas fan comes true and the Razorbacks beat Alabama, 100-3, I'm sure pollsters will find a place on their ballots for Arkansas.
NCAA Football Power Rankings
Next five: Oregon State, Florida, Mississippi State, BYU, Louisiana-Monroe
Andy Staples' Power Rankings also serve as his ballot in the Associated Press Top 25 poll.

Senior writer Andy Staples has covered college football for SI since 2008, developing an encyclopedic index of the best food in every college town along the way.
