Kansas State climbs, but much still unknown after four weeks of play

Judging by e-mail and Twitter responses, quite a few of you read these rankings each week and come away thinking I'm an idiot. Allow me to posit a question. How many more of you would feel that way if my Top 25 kicked off with the following five teams this week?
1. Oregon State
2. Stanford
3. Notre Dame
4. Iowa State
5. Texas
That is the actual top five this week from the computer ranking programmed by Kenneth Massey. (In case you're wondering, he has Alabama at No. 19.) His ranking is one of the six used by the BCS to determine which teams play for the national title. It counts for far more than my piddly AP ballot, which counts for nothing. Pretty outrageous, isn't it?
Not really. This is how rankings would look if you took away preseason poll bias and the dreaded "eyeball test," two things fans frequently suggest need to be eliminated from the process. So is that better?
Let's take a look at another poll used in the BCS formula that also eliminates preseason bias and the eyeball test. Here is this week's top five in Wes Colley's computer ranking:
1. Stanford
2. Notre Dame
3. Oregon
4. Florida
5. Oregon State
Once again, on-field results trump reputation and hype. And you probably think he's a bigger moron than you think I am.
Now let's look at the top five in those polls and the top five in the AP Poll at the end of the 2011 regular season.
Massey
1. LSU
2. Alabama
3. Arkansas
4. Oklahoma State
5. Kansas State
Colley
1. LSU
2. Oklahoma State
3. Alabama
4. Kansas State
5. Stanford
AP Poll
1. LSU
2. Alabama
3. Oklahoma State
4. Stanford
5. Oregon
The differences are minimal compared to the differences between those polls after four weeks of play. By December, the method used in the early weeks really doesn't matter that much. So relax. No matter how we vote or compute, we all pretty much arrive at the same place in December.
NCAA Football Power Rankings
Next five:Cincinnati, Michigan, Iowa State, Louisiana Tech, Ohio
Andy Staples' Power Rankings also serve as his ballot in the Associated Press Top 25 poll.

Senior writer Andy Staples has covered college football for SI since 2008, developing an encyclopedic index of the best food in every college town along the way.
