Georgia, Florida State losses pose familiar college coaching dilemma

Mea culpa: Staples' NC State, FSU apologySource:SI
Andy Staples offers an impassioned apology for calling NC State fans quiet and for hyping the 'Noles -- again.
Two items grabbed my attention during my Monday morning reading, and, while they were written from the perspectives of two different fan bases, they combined to form a fascinating question. First, I read this rumination on Georgia from Doug Gillett at SBNation.com that theorizes the Bulldogs have returned to "the Donnan phase" after getting punked once again by a Steve Spurrier team. Then I read the Twitter feed of Bud Elliott, who publishes the excellent Florida State blog Tomahawk Nation, as Elliott picked apart many of Jimbo Fisher's excuses for Florida State's loss at NC State Saturday.
Neither of these were overreactions to a bad loss. On the contrary, they were rational views of the programs the authors love. It just so happened that a horrible loss inspired each one. After reading both, I began to wonder: What should a program do when it has an obviously very good coach who can't seem to get his team over the hump to national title contention?
After referencing both pieces in one tweet, I posed that question on Twitter. The Georgia and Florida State fans chimed in, but even more interesting, Virginia Tech and Nebraska fans who missed the first tweet began writing in because they thought I had referred to their programs in the second tweet. And it is a puzzling quandary. The four programs I mentioned have had the type of recent success that at least 80 percent of the fan bases in the nation would give a limb for. But it isn't good enough for those particular schools. So where is the line? How long should a coach get to be consistently good without taking the program to an elite level before a school should make a change?
Even though I am a person who writes on the Internet and the Uniform Code of Internet Justice requires that all statements made on the Internet be definitive and declarative, I'm afraid this question has no correct answer. Ohio State finally fired John Cooper, and Jim Tressel took the Buckeyes to the level the fan base desired. On the flip side, Nebraska fired Frank Solich, and Bill Callahan ran the program into the ground.
Twenty years ago, Nebraska's Tom Osborne was allowed to be consistently good without winning the big one. Sure, there were complaints, but it wasn't such an instant-everything society back then. Then, when he finally broke through, Osborne won three national titles in four years. Florida State's Bobby Bowden faced similar circumstances. When he broke through, he won two national titles in six years.
Richt and Virginia Tech's Frank Beamer are obviously in very different places than Fisher and Nebraska's Bo Pelini. Beamer made Virginia Tech's program what it is; he is the Bobby Bowden of Blacksburg. Richt, meanwhile, is the SEC's longest-tenured coach, and he works for an athletic director (Greg McGarity) who doesn't make decisions on a whim. Fisher and Pelini are in their third and fifth seasons, respectively. (If it seems Fisher has been Florida State's head coach longer, that's because he took over the Seminoles' recruiting operation in 2007.) All four have frustrated their fans mightily this season and in past seasons, but the idea of making a change in any of the four cases seems silly and the product of unrealistic expectations. But are those expectations really unrealistic? Georgia shouldn't win a national title every year, but given its resources and its location in a recruiting hotbed, it should compete for one every few years. Ditto for Florida State, and, to a lesser extent, Virginia Tech. Nebraska is a different animal because of its isolated location, but that doesn't make the fan base crave national titles any less.
More than likely, the administrators at these schools will allow the coaches to keep doing the -- generally speaking -- fine work they've been doing through the years, even if that work is not fine enough to satisfy a healthy chunk of the fan base. Those fans will simply have to suffer the indignity of being merely above average until the coaches find a way to get over the hump or those administrators decide they can't wait any longer for the jump from good to excellent.
NCAA Football Power Rankings
Next five:Michigan State, TCU, Arizona, Oklahoma State, Ohio
Andy Staples' Power Rankings also serve as his ballot in the Associated Press Top 25 poll.

Senior writer Andy Staples has covered college football for SI since 2008, developing an encyclopedic index of the best food in every college town along the way.
