Skip to main content
SI

Remaining unbeatens could spark another late-season BCS dilemma

As we barrel toward a finish that may help prove why the BCS became a lame duck this past summer, various partisans will tout that a certain way of ranking

As we barrel toward a finish that may help prove why the BCS became a lame duck this past summer, various partisans will tout that a certain way of ranking teams is the only truly good way to rank teams. The reason? Because that particular ranking style puts the partisan's team in the BCS title game.

Things look messy now. At the moment, it's possible we might see an undefeated SEC champ, an undefeated Pac-12 champ, undefeated Kansas State and undefeated Notre Dame sitting atop the BCS standings on Dec. 2 with an undefeated Big East champ lurking somewhere in the top 10. Only two of those teams would be able to play for the national title, which would be an absolute disaster for the BCS if the people in charge hadn't already decided to scrap it. History tells us these entities won't all wind up undefeated and that the final rankings will be less messy than we think, but for a moment, let's imagine undefeated Chaos rules. (We'll ignore the most obvious solution: Realizing they could make a ton more money, conference leaders gather with bowl leaders and ESPN officials and quickly cobble together a two-year bridge deal and start the four-team playoff this season.)

Which teams would play for the title? Based on the current BCS rankings, the undefeated SEC champ (either Florida or Alabama) would face Kansas State. That would make some powerful people awfully angry, and rightfully so. But remember, the strength of schedule components used in the six computer rankings in the BCS formula only take into account games already played. Oregon's and Oregon State's strength of schedule will rise. Ditto for Notre Dame, which still must play at Oklahoma and USC. Because Kansas State has already played the best of the Big 12, its strength of schedule will not jump. That would leave the Wildcats vulnerable to a leap from the Pac-12 or from Notre Dame and would leave the Big 12 vulnerable to getting shafted by the BCS for the second consecutive season.

Oregon, because it is ranked No. 2 in both human polls and because it still must play USC, Stanford, Oregon State and probably USC again, would be the best candidate to jump someone. The Ducks are No. 6 or No. 7 in most of the computer polls because BCS leaders decided years ago that teams would run up the score if margin of victory were a component of the BCS selection process. They have refused to listen to calls for a limited margin-of-victory component -- capping the benefit at 21 points, for example -- that would help separate the teams that scrape by their opponents from the teams that crush their competition. This, by the way, is the same reason Alabama has threes, fours and fives sprinkled into its computer rankings. Jeff Sagarin's rankings at USA Today provide an excellent window into the difference a margin-of-victory component can make. The ELO_CHESS is not a '70s prog-rock band. It is the version of Sagarin's formula the BCS uses. Sagarin says ELO_CHESS is not as accurate in predicting future outcomes as his Pure Points Predictor rating, which does factor in margin of victory.

Here are Sagarin's ratings as used in the BCS:

1. Florida
2. Kansas State
3. Alabama
4. LSU
5. Notre Dame
6. Oregon State
7. Oregon

Here are Sagarin's ratings according to his Pure Points Predictor:

1. Alabama
2. Oklahoma
3. Florida
4. Oregon
5. Notre Dame
6. Kansas State
7. Texas A&M

And here is one idiot's opinion as to where the teams should be ranked...

NCAA Football Power Rankings

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Next five:Boise State, Texas, Ohio, Penn State, Arizona

Andy Staples' Power Rankings also serve as his ballot in the Associated Press Top 25 poll.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Published | Modified
Andy Staples
ANDY STAPLES

Senior writer Andy Staples has covered college football for SI since 2008, developing an encyclopedic index of the best food in every college town along the way.