Toledo was trailing 79-77 with 19 seconds left when Nathan Boothe drove the right baseline for a layup. Ohio's Antonio Campbell stripped the ball away for a steal as Boothe was going up. Jordan Lauf then fouled Treg Setty who made two free throws for an 81-77 lead.
Toledo's Jaelan Sanford was fouled as he missed a 3-point attempt with six seconds left. He made the first two and missed the third. Lauf grabbed the rebound and kicked the ball out to Jonathan Williams who missed a trey with two seconds left.
Campbell added 15 points, and Setty and Jaaron Simmons had 12 apiece for Ohio (12-7, 3-4 Mid-American Conference). Simmons also had 17 assists.
Boothe and Williams scored 21 points apiece for Toledo (12-8, 3-4).