Aaron Boone Says Isiah Kiner-Falefa Should've Been Considered For Gold Glove Award
In this story:
Finalists for this year's Gold Glove Awards were announced on Thursday and as always, the baseball world took to social media to critique which players made the cut.
For the Yankees, despite nominations at five different positions, there were two glaring omissions.
Third baseman Josh Donaldson, who did his best to make up for a down year on offense with a spectacular defensive season, was not among the three finalists at his position. Metrics suggest that Donaldson was arguably the best defender at third base in 2022.
Similarly, many view Aaron Judge as a snub in the outfield. The slugger continues to pass the eye test each year with highlight-reel plays and jaw-dropping throws, but he still hasn't been recognized in the Gold Glove department.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone weighed in on the announced finalists on Thursday afternoon. He told reporters, like Bryan Hoch of MLB.com, that "it's a joke" Donaldson wasn't a Gold Glove finalist, pointing out that Judge splitting time in right field and center field hurt his chances in 2022.
Boone continued, making a controversial (and slightly confusing) comment about his shortstop. The skipper said that a case can be made for Isiah Kiner-Falefa to be a finalist for a Gold Glove Award at shortstop this year.
This isn't the first time Boone has been complimentary to Kiner-Falefa and his defense. Back in July, Boone said "IKF" has been "one of the game's best defenders at shortstop."
And yet, Boone and the Yankees benched Kiner-Falefa for his defense at the end of the American League Division Series, moving Oswaldo Cabrera to shortstop for Games 4 and 5.
Kiner-Falefa started Game 1 of the American League Championship Game in Houston, but watched from the sidelines as top prospect Oswald Peraza made a few sparkling plays at shortstop in Game 2.
Some metrics are more kind to Kiner-Falefa than others. He was fourth in the American League among qualifying shortstops in defensive runs saved (plus-10), but tied for 11th in outs above average (minus-2). Kiner-Falefa committed 15 errors this season, sixth-most in the AL.
Starting pitcher Jameson Taillon, catcher Jose Trevino, first baseman Anthony Rizzo, left fielder Andrew Benintendi and utility man DJ LeMahieu were the other five Yankees listed as finalists.
MORE:
- Luis Severino: Alex Bregman Got 'Lucky' on Decisive Home Run in ALCS Game 2
- Why Haven’t the Yankees Used Domingo Germán?
- Matt Carpenter Focuses on Positives After Striking Out Four Times Against Astros
Follow Max Goodman on Twitter (@MaxTGoodman), be sure to bookmark Inside The Pinstripes and check back daily for news, analysis and more.
