Yankees Should Stop Sitting Ben Rice Against Lefties

It was feels like a self-inflicted wound for the New York Yankees to sit Ben Rice against lefties.

Apr 5, 2026; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees first baseman Ben Rice (22) reacts after hitting a three run home run against the Miami Marlins during the first inning at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John Jones-Imagn Images | John Jones-Imagn Images

The New York Yankees play lefty-righty matchups almost to their own detriment. It is to the point where, if they could pluck any guy who bats right-handed off the street to face a southpaw, they may go with them over Ben Rice.

For the second straight night, Rice sat on the bench. It worked out in game one against the Los Angeles Angels. The Yankees had a classic showdown, where they outlasted the Angels in what will surely become one of those Yankee Classics on the YES Network. Things were different in game two, though.

That high-scoring win almost feels like an outlier, whereas that 7-1 slogfest where the Yankees did little to get to Reid Detmers was the lackluster affair that has plagued them since last week. The Yankees treated Detmers, who had allowed eight earned runs in 15.2 innings pitched coming into that game, like he was the second coming of Chuck Finley or Jered Weaver. They had nothing for him all night.

Los Angeles Angels starting pitcher Reid Detmers (48) pitches in the first inning against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium. | Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images

Not having Rice in the lineup, given the team's propensity to struggle to score runs, feels like a self-inflicted wound. It's true that Rice hasn't hit lefties to the degree that he has hit right-handed pitching. His hitting .196/.274/.403 against them is a tangible explanation for why Aaron Boone kept him out of the game, but it isn't like the guys in his place are world beaters or even have a future on this team.

Goldschmidt has had success against lefties, hitting .336/.411/.570 off of them last year. At this point in his career, though, Goldschmidt is 38 years old, with 8,855 plate appearances under his belt. It was also clear that he wore down in the second half of last year.

It's not just Rice's detriment to have the kid gloves on him against lefties; if his contemporary at first wears down again, it's also a detriment to the Yankees at large. Rice may end up seeing his most repetitions against left-handed pitchers later in the year in games that matter more. That could be in late September if the Yankees find themselves in another tight division race or in the postseason. Why not let him figure it out when the stakes are lower?

Boone on Rice

Boone had a plan for Rice. He admitted as much before the loss. While Rice was relegated to a bench role for the second straight game, the goal was to get him into the game at some point. It wasn't a full-on off-day.

"I've just been able to so aggressively use Benny off the bench," Boone said, according to the New York Post's Greg Joyce. "Even though he's not in the starting lineup, I view him playing a major [role]. In the last two games, he's sat against a lefty, he's got [four] at-bats – homer, walk, single. I've been able to kind of fire him at the most important part, and it might be early in the game."

It was apropos that it played out exactly as Boone said it would. It was just about the only thing that went right.

Rice eventually entered the game. It happened in the bottom of the 8th with the Yankees down seven. With two outs, he hit a sacrifice fly, which scored Randal Grichuk.

It is quite fitting that, for the second night in a row a starter has come off the bench to do some damage. Last night, it was Trent Grisham, with his two-homer, 5-RBI masterpiece. That worked out more in the Yankees' favor.

Los Angeles Angels pitcher Jordan Romano (68) reacts after giving up a two run home run to New York Yankees center fielder Trent Grisham (not pictured) during the ninth inning at Yankee Stadium. | John Jones-Imagn Images

Rice's sacrifice fly did little to impact the game. All it did was keep them from getting shut out. Shut out or not, those losses all count the same, and the Yankees are becoming accustomed to it despite a hot start.

Rice gets the Yanks on the board with a sac-fly pic.twitter.com/b1gZqBsurS

— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) April 15, 2026

While the Yankees have this obsession with matchups, playing their best players would do them well at this point. It doesn't seem like the Grichuks of the world are going to turn things around. If he does, more power to him, because the Yankees need the firepower where they can get it, but it feels unlikely.