Skepticism about Bears runs high even after sound thumping of Eagles

In this story:
The Bears' surge and upset of Philadelphia seems to have captured the imagination of their fans and some others around the football world.
By and large, though, the Bears are given little chance of doing anything. Doubt remains high that they'll be around come the end of the wild card round.
At least it's progress. After they beat Pittsburgh, there were many giving them only about a 50-50 chance at being in the postseason even though they led the division.
Now, the Bears are top seeds in the NFC but their chances of even making the playoffs are rated far less by NFL.com than every other team currently in a seeded position.
Soon 🐻⬇️ pic.twitter.com/JfWK1AMPc6
— Ra…It’s Chicago!!!!🐻⬇️ (@Simpson3Ra) November 30, 2025
Their chances are 76% of being in the playoffs, while the second-seeded Rams are given a 96% chance of being a playoff team even after they lost Sunday to the Panthers. The Eagles are given a 95% chance at the playoffs despite being humbled on their own field by the Bears.
In case you're counting at home, that's a 19% better chance than the team seeded first who just gave them a physical beating. The Buccaneers are given an 86% chance of being in the playoffs. Even with Carolina hot on their heels, their chances are 10% better than the Bears' chances. The Packers are given an 11% better chance being in the playoffs.
The “worst 9-3 team ever” is now No. 1 in the NFC. pic.twitter.com/wWPCnUCBkJ
— Dave (@dave_bfr) November 30, 2025
At least the Bears are given a chance 34% better than the Lions (42%), after Detroit lost Amon-Ra St. Brown for a few weeks and Frank Ragnow and Sam LaPorta for the season.
NFL.com is hardly the unquestioned registrar of truth in the world, but this attitude toward the Bears looks similar with The Athletic. Their playoff chances calculator sets the Bears' chances at 72% for the playoffs and only 30% to win the division. They're given only a 7% chance by The Athletic of winning a playoff game.
The No. 1 seed in the NFC now belongs to the @ChicagoBears 🐻
— NFL+ (@NFLPlus) November 30, 2025
The last time the Bears held the #1 seed this late into a season was 2006. Ben Johnson was a backup QB at UNC and Caleb Williams had just turned 5 years old.#DaBears pic.twitter.com/KC7ngegSTE
The Athletic currently projects the Bears at 11-6 and in the seventh seed for the playoffs. They have the Packers beating them out for the division title at 11-5-1.
The website playoffstatus.com uses a method more in tune with the realities of this season. Their calculations say the Bears have a 90% chance at the playoffs, 8% better than the Packers. They're given a 57% chance of being around for the divisional playoffs and a 31% chance of making the NFC championship game. Their chance of making the Super Bowl is set at 15% and of winning the whole thing at 8%.
While 90% looks good, they're given less chance at the playoffs than the team they just beat (Philadelphia, 95%).
Bears fans know the season doesn’t end here. We have been terrible for so long, we are allowed to be excited about our progress. Stop treating us like we don’t know how a football season works. Believe me, WE KNOW. @ChicagoBears #beardown
— Anna Colwell (@realannacolwell) November 30, 2025
From the betting world, at DraftKings on Sunday night, the Bears are +160 to win the division but the Packers are favored at -140.
As for the NFC picture, the Bears (+1600) are given longer odds even than the Lions (+1400) of representing the NFC in the Super Bowl. That's the 7-5 Lions with key offensive players missing.
Game odds refresh periodically and are subject to change.
If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Coach of the Year Race looks like it’s coming down to Ben Johnson and Mike Vrabel.
— BearsShowYo (@BearsShowYo) November 30, 2025
Who do you think deserves it and why? pic.twitter.com/ShkUa4BTp0
More Chicago Bears News
X: BearsOnSI

Gene Chamberlain has covered the Chicago Bears full time as a beat writer since 1994 and prior to this on a part-time basis for 10 years. He covered the Bears as a beat writer for Suburban Chicago Newspapers, the Daily Southtown, Copley News Service and has been a contributor for the Daily Herald, the Associated Press, Bear Report, CBS Sports.com and The Sporting News. He also has worked a prep sports writer for Tribune Newspapers and Sun-Times newspapers.