Four Approaches the NY Giants Must Take This Summer

If the Giants truly want to be ready for Week 1 of the 2025 season, here are four things they need to look at doing (or in some cases, not doing).

Head coach, Brian Daboll as the New York Giants | Chris Pedota, NorthJersey.com / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The heat is on for the New York Giants–and we’re not just talking about the sweltering temperatures that are the norm this time of year in East Rutherford.

No, the Giants are in a position where they must improve upon the three-win seasons they posted last year. 

An upgraded roster has generated a lot of hope that Big Blue will at least be competitive against the league’s toughest strength of schedule. 

While the outcome of those upcoming games is still to be determined, there are steps that the Giants can and probably should take as they report to training camp today to ensure a successful 2025 campaign.

Injury Management 

Oct 20, 2024; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; New York Giants wide receiver Jalin Hyatt (13) walks off the field after an injury during the second half against the Philadelphia Eagles at MetLife Stadium. | Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

Injuries are going to happen–it’s football, after all. And while it’s understandable that medical personnel don’t want to put injured players out there to risk making something worse, which could render a player unavailable for Week 1, no one who participates in training camp practices will ever be truly 100%.

During the season, we often hear about players who push forward despite having ailments. The medical staff clears those players to participate in practices and football activities after it has been determined that they won’t exacerbate their condition. 

That same approach needs to be taken during the summer, where we see fewer players on the stationary bikes and in red jerseys than we’ve in past summers.

Hold Guys Accountable

Detailed view of a yellow penalty flag | Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

A significant problem for the Giants last year was penalties, particularly those related to pre-snap penalties and discipline issues. 

According to NFLPenalties.com, the Giants ranked above the league average in 15 different penalty categories last season, with the three most notable ones being illegal shift (-5.06), delay of game (-4.62), and false start (-3.91) – again, all pre-snap penalties. The Giants also had 41 stalled drives last season due to penalties, both pre- and post-snap.

That needs to be cleaned up, and that starts with holding individuals more accountable, regardless of their position or status. And there’s nothing wrong with putting guys on notice on the practice field, regardless of who they are.

We’re not suggesting that the players be made to run laps as Joe Judge used to have them do. Rather, pull them off the field or get in their faces if they have a concentration mistake.

Play the Starters/Key Reserves

New York Giants safety Jevon Holland | John Jones-Imagn Images

The last thing the Giants can afford this year is a slow start out of the gate, where they go winless in their first two games. 

That’s because those games are against division opponents (Washington and Dallas), and as anyone in the game will tell you, the easiest path to the postseason is to win in one’s division.

Unfortunately, over the last couple of years, the Giants have started the season looking sluggish and unprepared. This is largely due to head coach Brian Daboll’s decision not to give the starters and key reserves a healthy dose of preseason snaps.

Daboll, instead, has substituted joint practices for game snaps. That’s all well and good, but joint practice snaps are conducted in a controlled environment, and don’t necessarily help with establishing the tempo as one might in a game environment. 

This year, we hope that Daboll plays his starters for at least a half during the first and third preseason games, when there are no joint practices scheduled. 

The first game would give the coaches a rough idea of how things are taking shape with the players in pads. The third preseason game would serve as a final dress rehearsal.

While some teams can get away with not playing their starters in the preseason, these are generally the more successful or established ones. The Giants, by contrast, are neither.

There is one other advantage of getting their players' snaps in the final preseason game. There are 17 days in between the final preseason game on August 21 and the start of the regular season on September 7. 

If the Giants were to not give their starters and key players snaps in that third preseason game and instead gave them snaps in the second game, we’d be looking at 22 days.

In short, that’s way too long to let a team go without having reps at game speed. And it’s a legitimate reason as to why the Giants have not come out of the chute looking like they were ready to play.

---

What happens next with the NY Giants? Find out! Follow and like us on Facebook. Visit our YouTube channelfor the latest videos. Want to send a question in for our mailbag? You can do so here.

---

Stick with the Same Offensive Line Combination As Much as Possible

New York Giants offensive linemen | Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

One of the more disturbing developments from last summer is that the Giants rarely played their starting offensive line at all during the summer.

Some of that was due to injuries, and some was due to trying different players out along the line. 

While there is nothing wrong with experimenting with different combinations, there has to be a point where the coaches draw the line and start allowing the unit they plan to take into the season to start getting reps together to build cohesion, especially now that pads will be permitted in practice.