Ex-Steelers QB Fires Back at Adam Schefter Over Aaron Rodgers Rumor

PITTSBURGH -- The Pittsburgh Steelers are in the early months of the Mike McCarthy Era, and life has been good. A few roster questions remain, but there is a sense of trust building from the fanbase.

One of the most important unanswered questions is who will be the Steelers' starting quarterback in 2026? The presumed answer remains Aaron Rodgers, but no contract has been signed, and the 2026 NFL Draft is just weeks away.

Recently, former Steelers quarterback and co-host of The Snap Count, Charlie Batch, shared his thoughts on the holdup. He believes it's a financial dispute keeping things from moving forward, but ESPN's Adam Schefter refuted that claim. Now, Batch continues to hold firm to his stance, reaffirming it in the most recent episode of his show.

"I will stand ten toes down on this," he stated. "He deserves a pay raise. He's not gona play on the number he had last year. For people to say, 'He made a bunch of money,' it's not about money... This is about his services for this season."

Jan 12, 2026; Pittsburgh, PA, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) warms up before an AFC Wild Card Round game against the Houston Texans at Acrisure Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Barry Reeger-Imagn Images | Barry Reeger-Imagn Images

Could Money Be an Issue?

The reality is that there is no clarity regarding the situation. The Steelers have continued to present a positive front regarding the situation. McCarthy spouts off about how often he and Rodgers communicate. General manager Omar Khan and owner Art Rooney II have both shared the sentiment.

That's why many concluded that this waiting is just a formality, as the eccentric Rodgers takes his good ole time signing the deal. But that's never been confirmed. Batch might be right on the money regarding the situation. And as he explained, the $13 million salary he played on last year is not commensurate with the rate quarterbacks are paid in the NFL right now.

"That number is not going to be $13 million," Batch declared. "If you look at the rest of the league, he falls right into that $30 million range."

Where does that leave things between the Steelers and Rodgers, then?

What Number Makes Sense for Rodgers?

If Rodgers wants to be paid like a top-25 quarterback in the NFL, that would require the Steelers to cough up some more dough than they anticipate. The recent free-agent market set a baseline of $22 million. That's the average salary on the deal Malik Willis signed with the Miami Dolphins.

It seems that if Batch's analysis is correct, the Steelers have to pony up at least $20 million to get Rodgers back. Despite the pushback from national media and conflicting information about the subject, Batch is standing firm in the assertion that money is a huge factor preventing the Steelers from knowing their starting QB in 2026.

Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter for the latest news and updates on the Pittsburgh Steelers