Is There a Chance Caleb Downs Falls to the Vikings at Pick 18?

Much of the conversation around the Vikings' first-round pick at No. 18 overall has centered around Oregon safety Dillon Thieneman, who projects as a logical replacement for Minnesota if Harrison Smith ultimately elects to retire. Toledo's Emmanuel McNeil-Warren is another safety who could make a lot of sense for the Vikings at 18.

One thing we perhaps haven't spent enough time considering is this possibility: What if the top safety in the draft falls to Minnesota? Ohio State's Caleb Downs is viewed as a consensus top-ten overall prospect in this year's class, but it may not be crazy to think there's at least a chance he slips into the teens — and perhaps all the way to 18.

The case for a Downs slide, which was raised by @Krauserrific on Twitter, has a few main components. The first is that because of positional value, safeties — even the ones who are viewed as elite prospects — tend to fall down the board a bit on draft night. The others are specific to Downs. He did not do athletic testing at either the NFL combine or Ohio State's pro day. There was also a report coming out of the combine that he was flagged for a potentially degenerative knee condition, although others — and Downs himself — have pushed back against that notion.

If Downs were to go later in the draft than most mocks expect, it wouldn't be the first time that's happened to a top safety prospect. Only eight safeties have gone in the top 10 picks since 2000, with the most recent being Jamal Adams in 2017.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Highly-ranked safeties tend to fall in the draft

2018
Minkah 6th (by consensus board) --> #11 overall
Derwin 7th --> #21

2020
McKinney 21st --> #36

2021
Moehrig 25th --> #43

2022
Hamilton 4th --> #14

2023
Branch 16th --> #45

2024
Starks 16th --> #27

2025
Downs ??
— Krauser (@Krauserrific) April 2, 2026

Without all of the facts, it's hard to know what to make of the rumors surrounding Downs' knee and whether or not his medicals will be a factor of any kind in teams' draft decisions. Still, it is notable that he chose not to test in Indianapolis or at his pro day, especially for a player who isn't viewed as having truly elite raw athleticism.

Now, before Vikings fans get their hopes up, it's worth mentioning that this remains a long shot. Downs is talented enough to be a top-five pick, and if he makes it out of the top ten, it seems pretty likely that someone in the 11-17 range will have a hard time passing on him before the Vikings have a chance to draft him. But it's not impossible. And it's also worth considering the idea that Minnesota could trade up a few spots if he starts to slide.

If the Vikings were to somehow find a way to land Downs, he would be an incredibly fun addition to Brian Flores' defense. After beginning his career as a top-ten recruit in the country at Alabama, Downs transferred to Ohio State for his sophomore season and was a two-time All-American. He's racked up 16 TFLs, 6 INTs, 12 passes defended, and 3 forced fumbles in his three seasons, despite opposing offenses trying to avoid him as much as possible.

Caleb Downs text book open field tackle on Malachi Toney pic.twitter.com/YaECzqYjzS
— Ted Nguyen (@FB_FilmAnalysis) March 24, 2026

Downs earned a PFF grade above 85 in all three of his college seasons. He's a do-it-all safety who can cover, fire downhill as a run defender, and tackle in the open field. Whether he's lined up in the box or at nickel or at free safety, Downs uses his football IQ and playmaking skills to be consistently disruptive. He makes up for a lack of top-tier physical traits with his processing ability and instincts (and he's still a very good athlete, just not a truly freakish one).

Again, it's a long shot. But because of the position he plays and the lack of athletic testing, it's at least a possibility worth keeping in mind on April 23.