Oregon proves it's not soft in FSU rout
1:39 | College Football
Oregon proves it's not soft in FSU rout
Friday January 2nd, 2015

PASADENA, Calif. -- King Joffrey had a good run.

On Thursday night, however, the series came to an end for America’s favorite villain, as Jameis Winston and Florida State’s brilliant sprint through the college football record books came to a halt. It’s over. Kaput. See you next year.

It was 59-20 in the Rose Bowl and the first-ever College Football Playoff game and, yes, it was that ugly, after Oregon scored four touchdowns in a third quarter that left Florida State breathless and bewildered. At the end, it also left a blemish on a previously spotless record. Now it’s time to say goodbye to one of the best.

College Football
Oregon eyes national title, shatters soft label behind Rose Bowl blowout

Let’s be clear about one thing: Regardless of what you think about Winston as a person -- and there is undoubtedly a wide range of opinion -- he is a terrific football player. The 2013 Heisman Trophy winner led his team to 27 wins on the school’s ride to 29 in a row. That included the 2013 BCS title, a 34-31 win over Auburn in this very stadium that quieted, at least momentarily, the SEC-is-king talk.

Yes, he threw 17 interceptions coming into this game, but also 24 touchdowns and 3,559 yards. He rallied his teammates to numerous come-from-behind victories and brushed aside talk of being college football’s most-hated player. He is a far cry from America’s sweetheart, but can also be personable and funny and confident. And now his college career is likely a thing of the past.

Jeff Gross/Getty Images

Winston is a paradox who can’t decide if he wants to be the hero or the bad guy, which makes him intriguing. What role will he play in the NFL? Is he capable of change? When the clock hit zero and his Seminoles teammates fled to the locker room, humiliated and heartbroken, it was Winston who stuck around to shake hands with Oregon players. He tipped his helmet to the Florida State faithful on his way off the field, and seemed humbled. “That’s awesome,” Oregon defensive coordinator Don Pellum said of Winston’s postgame demeanor.

Moments later in the press conference tent, Winston delivered this line: “If everybody in this room just want to be real with themselves, this game could have went either way.”

Given the final score, there will be quite a few who take issue with that remark. But on this we can all agree: Winston did not play up to a Heisman winner’s standards on Thursday night. He finished 29-of-45 for 348 yards with a touchdown and an interception. This loss will not fall squarely on his shoulders, but two highlights (or lowlights, if you’re a Florida State fan) will be shown repeatedly.

The first, of Winston scrambling, stumbling and falling backward while fumbling, as Tony Washington scooped up the ball and ran 58 yards to the end zone, is when everything started to spiral. That Oregon score put the Seminoles in a 45-20 hole with 1:36 remaining in the third quarter. The second came moments later: Cameras focused on Winston on the sideline, screaming at coach Jimbo Fisher as Fisher told him, “If you don’t calm the f*** down, you’re going to the bench.”

College Football
Rose Bowl in review: Grades, social highlights from Oregon's win

Fisher said afterward he was simply asking Winston what happened on the play -- Winston told him one of Florida State’s receivers slipped on his route, forcing him to scramble -- and that Winston often gets “animated when he talks,” even when he’s playing well.

It was hardly the beginning of Florida State’s problems. The Seminoles’ narrative all season had been to fall behind, then capitalize on their foes’ second-half mistakes. On Thursday that narrative flipped, with the Ducks taking advantage of Florida State’s errors while the Seminoles looked around gasping for air and help (Oregon plays at breakneck speed). In the third and fourth quarters Florida State turned the ball over on five drives; each time Oregon responded with a touchdown.

The Ducks refused to believe it could be that easy. Early in the fourth quarter head coach Mark Helfrich told Pellum to think about pulling starters. “To be honest, I didn’t realize the score," Pellum said. "I didn’t know we were up 59-20.”

Two of Florida State’s turnovers came courtesy of freshman running back Dalvin Cook, the Seminoles’ best offensive option for the first 30 minutes. At halftime the 6-foot, 200-pounder had 90 yards on 12 carries, a 7.5 yards-per-carry clip. As media, fans and casual observers wondered why Fisher didn’t hand the ball to Cook every snap, it became clear(er) in the second half: He has a tendency to give it away. Cook fumbled twice, and Oregon turned both into scores. He finished with 15 carries for 103 yards, and no touchdowns.

Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

In a somber and almost silent postgame locker room, star Seminoles wide receiver Rashad Greene sighed deeply. Considered one of the biggest mismatches in the Rose Bowl, especially after Oregon’s All-America cornerback Ifo Ekpre-Olomu got hurt, Greene was held in check all night. He sympathized with Cook’s play, but said screaming at a rookie wouldn’t have helped.

“It just slipped away from us,” said Greene, who was held to six catches for 59 yards. “At the end, there was a little bit of reminiscing on the sideline, for what we did. We put this team back to where it belongs.”

For all of his off-field faults, Winston has been as big a part of that as anyone. Greene, as well as offensive lineman Cam Erving, took issue with the idea that Winston’s on-field legacy will be tarnished, or even changed, because of his third-quarter miscue. “Preposterous,” Erving said, shaking his head. Then, a pause and a deep breath. “He’s done everything for this team … Someday, we’ll be able to put it in perspective.”

Winston wasn’t ready to let go that easily. He claimed he hasn’t thought about the future, the looming NFL draft or the ‘Noles’ baseball season. (He is primarily used a closer for Florida State, recording seven saves in 2013.) He is forever confident -- and forever slightly unrealistic.

“Honestly, it was never over,” he said. “We just got beat, turned the ball over too many times. But it still ain’t over.”

Except that for Winston, it likely is.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.