Breaking Down the Extremely Complicated ABS Challenge That Gave Everyone a Lot to Think About

Mariners' victory over Twins featured a complex series of decisions for the umpiring crew.

Dan Wilson questions Doug Eddings about a complicated moment in the Mariners' win over Minnesota. | Foul Territory on X

After advancing to the American League Championship Series last year, the Mariners have been stuck in neutral during the early stages of this season. Manager Dan Wilson's club was able to notch a 7-1 victory over the Twins on Tuesday night to move to 15-16 on the year and get within one game of the Athletics for first place in the AL West. Josh Naylor hit a three-run homer and Julio Rodíguez stroked a two-run double to provide the offense, while the Seattle bullpen authored four scoreless innings to seal the win.

The night was not without some agitation for Wilson, however, as the manager did not care for the way a unique situation was handled in the top of the seventh. Below is video of the play that led to Wilson coming out of the dugout and giving a piece of his mind to home plate umpire Doug Eddings.

Dan Wilson wasn't thrilled about what he deemed to be a late ABS challenge by Victor Caratini that was granted.

Home plate umpire Doug Eddings: "I would do the same thing for your team." pic.twitter.com/q5bYyVwjMk

— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) April 29, 2026

Okay, so what exactly happened there?

The answer is a lot.

With a 2-1 count, Randy Arozarena laid off an offering from Twins starter Joe Ryan that was a borderline call near the top of the strike zone. Arozarena also appeared to check his swing. The confluence of these events created some work for Minnesota catcher Victor Caratini.

Once he heard Eddings rule the pitch a ball, he simultaneously tapped his head for an ABS challenge and asked for an appeal to the first base umpire on the swing decision. Eddings quickly granted the swing element of the request and Arozarena was determined not to have offered at the ball. Caratini's ABS appeal was initially not granted by Eddings, who could be seen shaking his head about something. That's when Twins manager Derek Shelton came out to give his insight on the situation, which was apparently enough to convince Eddings to initiate the replay review.

Video proved that Ryan's pitch actually nipped the strike zone and after all that, the count moved to 2-2. But the drama was not over as this development drew Wilson out onto the field for his own discussion with Eddings.

Wilson's beef was driven by a belief that Shelton had somehow changed Eddings's mind about allowing the ABS challenge. And one can understand frustrations as everyone adapts to a new world of baseball where there's a strict protocol in place to facilitate human-robot peer review.

Yet it does seem like Caratini did everything correctly and in the allotted time. He immediately tapped his helmet for the ball-strike call before pointing down to first base in an attempt to get a strike on the swing. Obviously there is no point in challenging whether a pitch was in the zone or not if a batter swings at it, so once that was ruled not to happen, then the location of the delivery could be examined.

Eddings seems to have handled everything properly in the end as well. It's not unreasonable to give umpires a tiny bit of grace as they sort through complicated moments like this in real-time. Anecdotally, this is the first time a check-swing/replay review situation has come across the transom for me so it's not like there's anything routine about it. Adding technology to the game and asking umpires to governor it with rulings that are essentially judgment calls is going to create oddities like this.

---