Mets manager opens up about 'difficult' roster decision

New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza has an interesting roster predicament on his hands.

Mar 28, 2025; Houston, TX, USA; New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza looks on from the dugout during the game against the Houston Astros at Daikin Park. Mandatory Credit: Troy Taormina-Imagn Images | Troy Taormina-Imagn Images

Once New York Mets veteran infielder Jeff McNeil went down with an oblique injury before 2025 Opening Day, there was some concern about whether New York would see production at second base in his stead.

Then again, given that McNeil hit .238 with a .692 OPS during the 2024 season, he wasn't guaranteed to be a major difference maker for New York.

It was clear that both Brett Baty and Luisangel Acuña would see time at the position while McNeil is out. But once both guys started the season off slow, Mets fans were eager for any positive updates on McNeil's recovery so that he could fill that role.

Read more: Insider explains Mets 'issue' with Brett Baty trade market

However, both Baty and Acuña have caught fire in the past week or so, being arguably the two top hitters in New York's lineup aside from Pete Alonso.

Both Luisangel and Brett are hitting their stride as Jeff McNeil's return looms 👀 pic.twitter.com/jf90ljf5wC

— MetsMuse (@MetsMuse) April 18, 2025

This success begs the question of how Mets manager Carlos Mendoza will allocate playing time between them right now, not to mention once McNeil returns. However, Mendoza doesn't seem overly concerned with this question, which he conveyed with a quote in an April 18 article from Mark W. Sanchez of the New York Post.

“Trying to find a balance to keep both somehow fresh with game action. They’re both playing well, so it makes it a lot harder,” Mendoza said of Acuña and Baty in the article. “But that’s a good problem to have.” 

When asked whether Acuña or Baty could assume the fourth outfielder spot once McNeil returns, Mendoza added, “Too early to tell. I think we’ll cross that bridge when we have to. They’re both playing well, so I hope that’s the case that it’s going to be a very difficult decision [of who leaves when McNeil joins].” 

Mets’ likely Luisangel Acuña-Brett Baty decision has become even more challenging https://t.co/Q5AK7OT8RL pic.twitter.com/9nJfBF85xM

— New York Post (@nypost) April 19, 2025

It will be fascinating to see how playing time shakes out between Baty, Acuña, and McNeil when he returns. But as Mendoza alluded to, this is a great problem to have.