Skip to main content

Joe Burrow vs Justin Herbert: NFL Analysts Debate Who They'd Prefer at Quarterback

Would you Rather Start a Franchise With Joe Burrow or Justin Herbert?

CINCINNATI — Joe Burrow and Justin Herbert both had impressive rookie campaigns last season. 

Burrow's season ended early due to a torn left ACL, meanwhile Herbert set the record for the most touchdown passes by a rookie in NFL history. 

The Good Morning Football crew was asked which quarterback they would start their franchise with moving forward. It led to an interesting debate between Peter Schrager, Nate Burleson and Kyle Brandt

"This might be the hardest question because I love both of these guys so much, but based on year one I'm gonna go with Justin Herbert," Schrager said. "Herbert comes in and lights up the league and here's the deal with him: physically he's a monster. Mentally he's a monster. He's a 4.0 GPA and a bio-engineering major. Everything he did last year was perfect. You can't go wrong with Burrow, but if I'm building a team right now I'm taking the guy that didn't have a season-ending ACL injury last year."

For more on the Bengals, including the latest news and breakdowns, subscribe to our YouTube Channel

There are plenty of people that would take Herbert over Burrow at this point. Not only because of health, but because of his physical traits. He's big, strong, athletic and can throw the ball deep downfield with ease. 

Despite Herbert's physical abilities, Burleson went in a different direction.

"Injury aside, I like what I saw from Joe Burrow a little bit more," Burleson said. "I just love Joe Burrow. I love everything about him. Even dating back to his college film and not just his college film, [but] when he's caught on film. I know I keep talking about some of these intangibles and things that you can't necessarily quantify, but when you're sitting back and you got that cigar in your mouth, that just shows me that you got it figured out. And he's mature. He's not a young rookie. He was an older rookie last season so going into his sophomore season, he's a lot more mature than most quarterbacks that are in his group. So for me I'm going with Joe Burrow, I think he's going to light it up this year."

Burrow's leadership is one of his best qualities. People in the Bengals organization had high expectations for him last season and he exceeded them—both on and off the field. 

"I'm going with Burrow too and it's not the practical answer, I get it. Herbert did look good and Burrow did get hurt," Brandt said. "It's something intangible about Joe Burrow. I see him and I want to be in the huddle with him. I want to go to battle with him. I think he's got this it and this moxie that maybe Herbert will develop and continue to cultivate. This is a very tough question. Herbert looks fantastic. I don't know. There's something about if I'm going into a dark alley, I just know Joe Burrow's going to be there for me. Herbert probably will be too, but I know Burrow is. It's intangible as hell, but I'm going with my gut on this."

Burrow ultimately received two votes to Herbert's one, but it is an interesting debate. 

Both teams added talent this offseason. They also have unproven coaches. Those are two major factors that will impact how we view Burrow and Herbert moving forward.

Make sure you bookmark AllBengals for the latest offseason news, rumors and more!


You May Also Like:

Pooka Williams Made Quite an Impression on the Bengals' Coaches

Cincinnati Should Add a Veteran O-Lineman Before Training Camp

Bengals on the Hunt for a Game Changing Punt Returner

Joe Mixon Unhappy With NFLPA Following Latest COVID-19 Protocols

Joe Burrow Impresses in 7-on-7s as Bengals Spring Ends Early

Jessie Bates Focused on Winning With Contract Talks Looming

Bengals OL Hakeem Adeniji to Miss Significant Time With Pec Injury

Watch: Highlights of Joe Burrow and Others From Bengals Minicamp

Bengals Add Five Interns to Zac Taylor's Staff

Joe Burrow, Rest of Bengals' Stars Shine Bright on Media Day

Auden Tate Wears Bengals' New Uniforms For First Time

Sean McVay Talked With Zac Taylor About Joe Burrow & Ja'Marr Chase

Bengals Cornerback Chidobe Awuzie Receives Big Time Praise

Zac Taylor Compares Ja'Marr Chase to Cooper Kupp in Two Key Areas

Analyst Makes BOLD Prediction for Burrow and the Bengals' Offense

Watch: Quality Breakdown of Bengals' OTAs

Jessie Bates Leads Way as Bengals' Secondary Receives Praise

Analysts Asks Important Question About Joe Burrow and the Bengals

Joe Mixon Breakout Incoming? Zac Taylor Endorses His Star RB

Check Out the Best Photos From the Bengals Third Week of OTAs

Tee Higgins Surprised by Joe Burrow's Increase in Velocity

Bengals Offensive Line Ranked Higher Than Expected

Watch Highlights From Week 3 of Bengals OTAs

Former NFL Wide Receiver Buying Stock in Tee Higgins

Look: A.J. Green Wears a Cardinals Jersey for the First Time

Randy Bullock is Headed to the Hall of Fame

LeBron James, Other Athletes React to Chad Johnson's Boxing Debut

Joe Burrow High on Latest Power Rankings for Comeback Player of the Year

Bengals Banking on Ja'Marr Chase to be Significant Upgrade in Wide Receiver Room

C.J. Uzomah Wants to be Like Tom Brady

Exclusive: Tee Higgins Poised for Big Leap in Year Two

Watch: Joe Burrow Throws 60-Yard Bombs at Bengals Practice

Joe Burrow's Velocity Up in OTAs: "Tight Coverage Won't Matter"

Data Says Joe Burrow, Bengals Should Make Leap in 2021

Watch: Joe Burrow Throws on the Move During OTAs

Bengals Quarterback Joe Burrow Tweaked Throwing Motion This Offseason

Joe Burrow Making Progress, Here's the Latest on His Recovery

Two Bengals Make List of Top 25 Players Under 25-years-old

Look: Joe Burrow Projected to Have Big Season

Zac Taylor Among Favorites to Be First NFL Head Coach Fired This Season

Look: Odds on Joe Burrow and Joe Mixon's Comeback Player of the Year Chances


Be sure to keep it locked on AllBengals all the time!

Subscribe to the AllBengals YouTube channel
Follow AllBengals on Twitter: @AllBengals

Like and follow AllBengals on Facebook