Skip to main content
Eagles Today

Sean Mannion Is Officially in the Hot Seat as Eagles Return to Action in Week 11

It's put-up-or-shut-up time for Philadelphia's offensive coordinator.
It's time for OC Sean Mannion to prove his worth to the Eagles if he wants to avoid being a one-hit wonder this season.
It's time for OC Sean Mannion to prove his worth to the Eagles if he wants to avoid being a one-hit wonder this season. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

In this story:

PHILADELPHIA, P.A. — The Eagles’ bye week is over. The self-scout is done. The excuses have a shelf life, and that shelf life expires for Sean Mannion on Sunday against the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Mannion’s first season as Eagles offensive coordinator has been a disaster. The numbers are ugly. The process has looked messy. The results have been even worse. 

Head coach Nick Sirianni—and by extension, GM Howie Roseman and owner Jeffrey Lurie—has stuck by the unconventional hire through a seven-game losing streak and a 2-7 record overall. That said, any patience that was granted in September and October due to the attrition now has to be earned in the final eight games if Mannion wants any hope of a sequel. 

Patience is running out for Sean Mannion in Philadelphia

Getting back starting receivers DeVonta Smith and Dontayvion Wicks, and potentially running back Will Shipley, does not require a 180-degree transformation. It does require proof that Mannion can elevate players through adversity instead of simply managing their absences.

Smith and Wicks have been the clearest examples of Mannion's rocky start. When both receivers have been healthy, the offense has at least looked like it has a pulse. When they have not, the drop-off has been steep, and the supporting cast has not been maximized. 

That is the difference between a coordinator who is scheme-centric and one who gets the most out of what is available on a given Sunday. 

Sean Mannion hands on his hips.
Sean Mannion needs to show the Eagles he can deliver offensive success, regardless of who's available. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Smith remains elite when healthy and is the most reliable separator on the roster; Wicks has shown he can win with his route running. Reintegrating both should make the passing game less one-dimensional, even with the inexperienced Joe Milton at the controls. 

If the same late-to-the-line, overloaded-at-the-snap issues that have plagued the unit persist even with those two back, you can rest assured the problem is not solely personnel.

Shipley’s potential return also adds another layer. He is not Saquon Barkley, but he is a legitimate complementary back who can handle a share of the load and contribute to the passing game. 

The Eagles have been thin at running back for large stretches of this season. Adding a functional piece behind Barkley should help. It also gives Mannion another chance to show he can build a more balanced attack rather than leaning on whatever is least injured against Pittsburgh.

The bye week gave the staff time to self-scout without the immediate pressure of a game plan. The Eagles also added old friend T.J. Paganetti, a run-game specialist, as a consultant on Monday. Those levers have to prove to be useful. 

Any film sessions and schematic adjustments only matter if they show up in how the offense performs against the Steelers, an AFC playoff contender that hasn’t won in Philadelphia since 1965. 

Setting realistic expectations

The Eagles don’t need Mannion to suddenly become the next Sean McVay. They do need him to demonstrate that his system can still function when key pieces are available, that the communication issues can be cleaned up, and that available players can be put in positions to succeed rather than simply asked to survive.

It’s esoteric and somewhat intangible, but that’s the bar for continued patience. Not a complete overhaul. Not a sudden jump into the top half of the league in scoring. Just clear evidence that the coordinator can raise the level of the players he has when they are actually on the field. 

If that evidence does not appear soon, the conversation around the rest of the season will shift from “give Mannion time” to speculation about the next OC.

The bye was the intermission after a disastrous first act. Sunday is Mannion's first opportunity to prove that lessons were learned during the adversity.

Get Eagles On SI straight to your inbox: sign up for our free newsletter here.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Published
John McMullen
JOHN MCMULLEN

John McMullen is a veteran reporter who has covered the NFL for over two decades. The current NFL insider for JAKIB Media, John is the former NFL Editor for The Sports Network where his syndicated column was featured in over 200 outlets including the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, and Miami Herald. He was also the national NFL columnist for Today's Pigskin as well as FanRag Sports. McMullen has covered the Eagles on a daily basis since 2016, first for ESPN South Jersey and now for Eagles Today on SI.com's FanNation. You can listen to John, alongside legendary sports-talk host Jody McDonald every morning from 8-10 on ‘Birds 365,” streaming live on YouTube.com. John is also the host of his own show "Extending the Play" on AM1490 in South Jersey and part of 6ABC.com's live postgame show after every Eagles game. You can reach him at jmcmullen44@gmail.com or on Twitter @JFMcMullen

Share on XFollow JFMcMullen