Inside The Mariners

Brady's Spin: Ty France Will Be Honored By Seattle Mariners, But We've Taken Tributes Too Far

Ty France returns to Seattle for the first time as a member of the Minnesota Twins on Friday night, and it's certain that the team will pull out all the stops to welcome him back. However, I think we, as a society, have taken the tributes too far.
Minnesota Twins first baseman Ty France (13) dives to first base for a force out on a ball hit by Kansas City Royals first baseman Vinnie Pasquantino (9) during the eighth inning at Target Field on May 25.
Minnesota Twins first baseman Ty France (13) dives to first base for a force out on a ball hit by Kansas City Royals first baseman Vinnie Pasquantino (9) during the eighth inning at Target Field on May 25. | Matt Krohn-Imagn Images

In this story:


On Friday night, Minnesota Twins' first baseman Ty France returns to Seattle for the first time as a member of an opposing team. France, acquired by the Mariners in 2020, was a major factor in the team's roster through June of 2024, when he was designated for assignment.

I have no doubt that France will get a rousing ovation and a video tribute from the organization, and while I think he deserves it in today's sports climate, I think that sports climate has gone a little too far.

I discussed this further on the most recent edition of the Refuse to Lose podcast:

Welcome ​back, Ty ​France. ​Ty France, I'm ​positive ​of ​it, ​is ​going ​to ​get ​a ​video ​tribute ​from ​the ​Mariners. ​He ​probably ​deserves ​it, ​although ​I ​do ​think, as ​a ​society, we've ​gone ​a ​little ​too ​heavy ​on ​the ​video ​tributes. ​Ty France ​was ​a ​career. 266 ​hitter ​with ​the ​Mariners. ​He ​made ​one ​All-Star ​Game. ​He ​was ​a ​part ​of ​one ​playoff ​team. ​His ​average ​regressed ​every ​single ​year ​that ​he ​was ​in ​Seattle. ​Right? He ​hit .302 ​when ​he ​came ​over ​in ​the ​2020 ​season. ​Only ​23 ​games. ​He ​hit .291 ​in ​2021. ​He ​hit .274 ​in ​2022. ​He ​hit .250 ​in ​2023, ​and ​he ​hit .223 ​before ​they ​got ​rid ​of ​him ​after ​88 ​games ​in ​2024. ​So, Ty ​France, ​I ​think, to ​me, ​gets ​more ​credit ​for ​what ​he ​helped ​build ​culture-wise ​in Seattle ​than ​for ​what ​he ​actually ​did ​on ​the ​field. ​

The ​fans ​will ​embrace ​him. Again, he'll ​get ​the ​curtain ​call ​or ​the '​standing ​O' in ​his ​first ​at ​bat. ​He'll ​tip ​his ​hat ​to ​the ​crowd. ​He'll ​get ​a ​video ​tribute. ​It ​seems ​a ​little ​overboard ​for ​the ​kind ​of ​player ​that ​Ty ​was ​in ​Seattle, ​but ​given ​where ​we ​are ​as ​a ​society, ​he ​probably ​deserves it.

You can hear the full podcast in the player below:

France is hitting .254 for the Twins right now with four homers and 30 RBIs.

First pitch is set for 7:10 p.m. PT as Bryan Woo pitches against Zebby Matthews. Both teams are 30-25.

Related Stories on Seattle Mariners

NEW PODCAST IS OUT! Brady is back for another episode of "Refuse to Lose," as he talks about the disappointing loss on Thursday against the Nationals and the bullpen decisions that took place in it. Furthermore, where has the offense from April gone? How concerned are we about George Kirby? And what are all the big roster decisions that this team has to make moving forward. CLICK HERE:

NO QUESTION: According to ESPN researcher Paul Hembekides, there's "no question," that Cal Raleigh is the best catcher in the league. CLICK HERE:

THAT's LIFE in BASEBALL: Logan Evans's recent demotion might not be fair, but it's totally understandable from the Mariners' perspective. CLICK HERE:

Follow Seattle Mariners on SI on social media

Continue to follow our Inside the Mariners coverage on social media by liking us on Facebook and by following Teren Kowatsch and Brady Farkas on "X" @Teren_Kowatsch and @RefuseToLosePod. You can subscribe to the "Refuse to Lose" podcast by clicking HERE.


Published