Inside The Mariners

Former Seattle Mariners Coach Discusses Team's Decision to Rebuild After 2018 Season

The Seattle Mariners went 89-73 during the 2018 season, but they elected to trade off key players like James Paxton, Robinson Cano, Edwin Diaz and Jean Segura. We revisited that situation with former M's coach Scott Brosius, who joined the most recent edition of the "Refuse to Lose" podcast.
Seattle Mariners third baseman Kyle Seager (15) high fives Seattle Mariners third base coach Scott Brosius (28) after hitting a triple during the eighth inning against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Park in Arlington in 2018.
Seattle Mariners third baseman Kyle Seager (15) high fives Seattle Mariners third base coach Scott Brosius (28) after hitting a triple during the eighth inning against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Park in Arlington in 2018. | Shane Roper-Imagn Images

In this story:


The 2018 Seattle Mariners went 89-73 for the season and missed the playoffs, continuing a playoff drought that had existed since the start of the 2002 season. Though the drought was eventually broken in 2022, that season represented a turning point for the organization.

Following the season, the M's elected to rebuild, trading away James Paxton, Robinson Cano, Jean Segura and Edwin Diaz. The M's acquired veterans like Edwin Encarnacion and Jay Bruce, only to trade them away as well over the course of the year. The 2019 Mariners went 68-94 and finished in last place in the American League West.

We caught up with former Mariners coach Scott Brosius on the most recent edition of the Refuse to Lose podcast to talk about the 2018 season, the decision to rebuild and much more:

Question (paraphrase): Scott, I believe you when you say you didn't leave because a rebuild was coming, but was there a sense that one was coming after that 2018 season?

Answer (exact): ​There ​was. ​I ​think ​there ​was ​honest ​conversations ​about ​that. ​And ​the ​truth ​was, ​I ​think ​It ​was ​the ​right ​move ​to ​make. The ​reality, ​if ​you ​look ​back ​at ​it ​with ​just ​an ​honest set ​of ​eyes, ​we ​weren't ​winning ​at ​the ​time with ​that ​roster. ​I ​mean, we ​were ​close, ​but ​we ​really ​hadn't ​been ​able ​to ​push ​through ​and ​win. ​And ​so ​I ​think ​there ​was ​some ​recognition ​like, ​'hey, ​if ​we're ​going ​to ​get ​to ​where ​we ​want ​to ​get ​to, ​we ​got ​to ​do ​it ​in ​a ​little ​different ​way.' ​And ​so, ​that ​wasn't, ​for ​me, ​that ​wasn't ​the ​reason. They ​were ​a ​little ​bit ​more ​I ​think, ​personal, ​family ​and ​just ​other ​opportunities. ​Like ​I ​said, ​just ​a ​unique ​opportunity ​to ​maybe ​do ​something ​else ​that ​I ​would ​really ​love ​and ​maybe ​not ​be ​on ​the ​road ​as ​much ​as ​I ​was. ​So ​it ​was kind of ​a ​combination ​of ​things. ​But ​it ​wasn't ​necessarily ​because ​of ​the ​experience ​that ​I ​had ​there ​or ​the ​direction ​the ​team ​was ​going. ​Like ​I ​said, ​I ​was ​really proud ​to ​wear ​the ​uniform ​and ​really appreciative of the opportunity.

Brosius played 11 years in the big leagues with the Athletics and the New York Yankees. He won three World Series titles in New York and coached from 2016-2018 in the M's organization.

You can listen to the full interview as part of the podcast below:

Related Stories on Seattle Mariners

NEW PODCAST IS OUT! Brady is back for another episode of "Refuse to Lose," talking about the M's recent struggles and why he's still not worried yet. Then, he talks about the problems with the starting rotation and how its hurting the rest of the operation. Finally, we are joined by former Mariners coach and three-time World Series champion Scott Brosius, who talks about his career and his time in Seattle. And Brady has a message for "fans" in the wake of what happened to Astros' pitcher Lance McCullers Jr. CLICK HERE:

WELCOME BACK, DAVE!: Former broadcaster Dave Sims, who left the M's after 18 seasons, is back in town for the first time since taking the New York Yankees' radio job. CLICK HERE:

HISTORY ON TWO FRONTS: Leody Taveras, recently acquired by the M's, put together some interesting history, both offensively and defensively, against Toronto on Saturday. CLICK HERE:

Follow Seattle Mariners on SI on social media

Continue to follow our Inside the Mariners coverage on social media by liking us on Facebook and by following Teren Kowatsch and Brady Farkas on "X" @Teren_Kowatsch and @RefuseToLosePod. You can subscribe to the "Refuse to Lose" podcast by clicking HERE.