All 49ers

49ers face uncomfortable questions after Brock Purdy reinjures toe

This is troubling.
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy (13).
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy (13). | Darren Yamashita-Imagn Images

In this story:


The San Francisco 49ers cannot catch a break when it comes to injuries, and it may have become even worse last week. The return of Brock Purdy has been derailed by a setback and he may now miss more time. 

San Francisco 49ers may be without Brock Purdy for even longer

Purdy was injured in Week 1 with turf toe. He missed Weeks 2 and 3, but came back in Week 4, despite the team being 2-0 without him. Whether Purdy came back too early or just so happened to get injured in a similar fashion, it turned into a setback. 

This is going to cause the team to start Mac Jones this week, and potentially into the future as well. The team, fortunately, gets 10 days off after this short week, but that may not be enough time for Purdy to return. Now, the question is how many games does Purdy miss?

There are a lot of what-ifs that come from this news as well. Did Purdy come back too early? If Mac Jones played poorly, but they still won, would he have pushed to come back as soon? Of course, the other question is why the 49ers did not hold him back one more week just in case. They knew that Purdy had a short week against the Rams coming; why not just rest him for that game?

San Francisc
Darren Yamashita-Imagn Images

The 49ers have not been getting the benefit of the doubt when it comes to handling injuries. 

Christian McCaffrey is playing, but is not quite as explosive as a runner this season. Of course, all three of their starting wide receivers are hurt and Nick Bosa is out. Some of this is sheer bad luck. Some of this you have to tie to the 49ers after such a long list of injuries. 

The last question comes down to the contract that Purdy just got. Perhaps Purdy came back too soon because he felt a need to live up to that deal. However, Purdy is now the long-term thought at quarterback. The team has to be cautious and has to be viewing the bigger picture as the most important feature of his career. 

There are also going to be questions about whether or not Purdy can live up to that salary. Injuries are becoming a serious part of his career, and once the team signed him, they are already seeing some of the downfalls of the deal.

read more


Published | Modified
Parker Hurley
PARKER HURLEY

Parker Hurley is a Pittsburgh native and IUP alumni with a deep-rooted passion for football and a decade of experience analyzing the game. Since 2016, he had extensively covered the Chicago Bears, serving as the site manager for Bear Goggles On from 2017 to 2023. During that time, Parker published hundreds of articles per month and led content strategy across written, audio, and video formats. Parker has also produced podcasts, blogs, and YouTube content focused on the Pittsburgh Steelers, NFL betting trends, and league-wide analysis. His work blends film breakdowns, statistical insight, and timely news reaction to deliver clear, actionable content for fans and bettors alike. Now, Parker contributes NFL coverage across multiple platforms, expanding his scope to include teams like the San Francisco 49ers and broader NFL narratives. Whether he’s analyzing rookie development or evaluating playoff contenders, Parker’s top priority is helping readers understand the game on a deeper level. He brings passion, clarity, and consistency to everything he writes, always aiming to educate, engage, and elevate the football conversation.

Share on XFollow parkerhurley