Seahawks' Sam Donald drops, Russell Wilson plummets in new NFL QB rankings

In this story:
He wasn't as good as Geno Smith. But he was better than Russell Wilson.
In the end, new Seattle Seahawks' quarterback Sam Darnold is sandwiched somewhere between his two predecessors. According to The Athletic's weekly NFL quarterback rankings he's still a middle-of-the-pack performer.
MORE: Geno Smith far outdid Sam Darnold in respective debuts, analyst claims
In his Seahawks' debut, Darnold had a chance to make quite the favorable impression. With completions of 11 and 40 yards to Jaxon Smith-Njigba, he drove Seattle inside San Francisco's 10-yard line in the final minute down only 17-13 at a deafening Lumen Field.
But instead of a game-winning play, Darnold produced, well, a Darnold. Bumped into my right tackle Abe Lucas - who was shoved into his lap by 49ers' rusher Joey Bosa - Darnold fumbled and that was it.
He threw for only 150 yards, but had his team in position to win. Until he didn't.
MORE: Sam Darnold rejects idea that he should have seen more preseason snaps
For his crunch-time turnover, Darnold dropped from No. 14 to 17 in The Athletic's rankings. For guiding his Las Vegas Raiders to a road win over the Patriots, Geno Smith jumped from 17 to 15. And Wilson, who led the Seahawks to their only Super Bowl, was the week's biggest dropper - from 25 to 30 - after failing to lead the New York Giants to a touchdown in their loss at Washington.
The Top 5 remained the same although with a bit of shuffing: 1. Josh Allen, 2. Lamar Jackson, 3. Patrick Mahomes, 4. Joe Burrow, 5. Jayden Daniels. The biggest jump of the week was by the Chargers' Justin Herbert, who moved into the Top 10 at No. 9 after upsetting the Chiefs in Brazil.

More Seahawks on SI stories
Seahawks studs & duds from heartbreaking Week 1 loss to 49ers
Takeaways from Seahawks’ loss to 49ers in 2025 season opener
Riq Woolen beaten on 2 crushing plays in Seahawks loss to 49ers
CBS names cornerback Seahawks’ biggest remaining roster need

Richie Whitt has been a sports media fixture in Dallas-Fort Worth since graduating from UT-Arlington in 1986. His career is highlighted by successful stints in print (Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Dallas Observer), TV (NBC5) and radio (105.3 The Fan). During his almost 40-year tenure, he's blabbed and blogged on events ranging from Super Bowls to NBA Finals to World Series to Stanley Cups to Olympics to Wimbledons to World Cups. Whitt has been covering the NFL since 1989, and in 1993 authored The 'Boys Are Back, a book chronicling the Dallas Cowboys' run to Super Bowl XXVII.
Follow richiewhitt