NFL Draft 2026 Fantasy Rookie Winners and Losers in Round 1

Get NFL prospect scouting reports, live first-round grades and team breakdowns in SI’s draft tracker.

The 2026 NFL draft is finally here!

Not only will this event help shape the future of all 32 NFL teams, but it also will have a massive impact in the fantasy football world. While talent is obviously huge for a player’s value, their ultimate landing spot can, in many cases, be just as important to determining a rookie’s stock.

In the interest of giving you immediate gratification, I’ll be giving you instant analysis for each offensive skill player picked in the first three rounds of the draft. Let’s kick things off with the first round and all of the fantasy-relevant selections from Thursday night’s first 32 picks!

Winners

Fernando Mendoza, QB, Raiders: Mendoza is an accurate pocket passer who won a national championship with Indiana and will now be the Raiders’ franchise quarterback. I don’t think he’ll make an immediate fantasy impact (Kirk Cousins could be under center in Week 1), so don’t be shocked if he’s drafted very late or not at all in traditional, one-quarterback leagues. Long term, I can see Mendoza being a very good, but not great or elite, fantasy signal-caller.

Jeremiyah Love, RB, Cardinals: Arizona isn’t the best landing spot for Love, at least for Year 1, as the Cardinals signed Tyler Allgeier and still have James Conner and Trey Benson on the roster. Still, he’s far and away the best running back in this class, and he’ll be the lead back in Arizona from Day 1. I do worry that he’ll lose carries to Allgeier like as Bijan Robinson did in Atlanta, but Love will still be the first rookie picked in all redraft and dynasty leagues.

Carnell Tate, WR, Titans: The Titans had a huge need at wide receiver, and Tate fits the bill. Arguably the top wideout in the class, he will immediately become the top option in the pass attack for QB Cam Ward. Coming from “Wide Receiver U,” Tate comes from a long line of Ohio State wideouts who have made a quick fantasy impact at the next level. He’ll be in the WR3/flex starter mix based on volume alone in the offense of new coordinator Brian Daboll.

Carnell Tate is going to the Tennessee Titans, but will he be a fantasy football monster in his rookie season? Find out why Tate landed in the perfect spot to do just that.@SInow pic.twitter.com/QjrGJc8A5x
— Michael Fabiano (@Michael_Fabiano) April 24, 2026

Jordyn Tyson, WR, Saints: Tyson is arguably the most physically gifted wide receiver in this class, and playing in the offense of head coach Kellen Moore will do nothing but help him at the next level. He likely won’t make a huge Year 1 impact with Chris Olave serving as the top option in the pass attack, but I can see Tyson being a potential flex starter as long as he can avoid injuries. His presence in the offense will make QB Tyler Shough an even bigger fantasy sleeper.

Kenyon Sadiq, TE, Jets: I thought the Jets would go with a wide receiver at No. 16, but instead they drafted the best tight end in the class. Sadiq is an athletic freak who torched the NFL scouting combine, and he reminds me a lot of Vernon Davis given his physical build and skill set. I could see Sadiq being one of the top options in the offense behind Garrett Wilson and bringing back starting value in fantasy leagues in Year 1. On the flip side, the presence of Sadiq all but squashes the fantasy sleeper appeal of TE Mason Taylor.

Makai Lemon, WR, Eagles: The Eagles traded with the rival Cowboys (strange, right?) to get their hands on Lemon with the 20th overall pick. It’s a great move for his fantasy football value, as Lemon will come right in and become the second-best option in the passing game behind DeVonta Smith. I could see him bringing back low WR2/WR3 value in Year 1. The selection of Lemon is further proof that star receiver A.J. Brown will be traded after June 1, likely to the New England Patriots .

KC Concepcion, WR, Browns: The Browns don’t have a lot of reliable playmakers in their pass attack, so adding Concepcion makes a lot of sense. He reminds scouts of Zay Flowers, who was coincidentally (or not) coached by new Browns head coach Todd Monken in Baltimore. Concepcion did have some problems with drops in college, but I still see him as the most attractive fantasy wide receiver in Cleveland, ahead of veterans Jerry Jeudy and Cedrick Tillman.

Losers

Ty Simpson, QB, Rams: The first “wow” moment of the draft came when the Rams took Simpson at No. 13. He has no chance to be the Rams’ starting quarterback anytime soon with Matthew Stafford ahead of him, so his redraft value is basically null and void. I will say this … if you play in a dynasty league, this was probably the best-case scenario for Simpson to become a potential fantasy asset in the future. But in redraft leagues, Simpson has no value.

Omar Cooper Jr., WR, Jets: I love Cooper’s game, as he’s a physical and versatile player who reminds me a lot of a lighter Deebo Samuel Sr. So, why is he a loser? Well, the Jets have had a very good draft and suddenly have a bunch of mouths to feed. Along with fellow rookie Kenyon Sadiq, Cooper Jr. will also have to contend with Garrett Wilson, Adonai Mitchell, and to a lesser degree, Mason Taylor. I like Cooper long term, but his Year 1 impact could be limited.

More NFL on Sports Illustrated

Add us as a preferred source on Google