Caleb Williams vs. Jayden Daniels, the heated debate that will never end

The Commanders’ Wild Card victory ignites the Caleb/Jaden discourse. Again.

Is Caleb Williams giving the stink-eye to somebody who claims he's not as good as Jayden Daniels? | Daniel Bartel-Imagn Images

Last night, rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels led his Washington Commanders to a last-gasp 23-20 road victory over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Last night, rookie quarterback Caleb Williams did…something. We can't know what, because Chicago’s signal caller wasn’t on national television.

As the two field generals were picked one and two in their draft class, the Caleb vs. Jayden comparisons are going to be a thing for their entire careers:

• Who’s better?

• Who will be better?

• Will Caleb grow in year two?

• Will Jayden regress in year two?

• Which team got it right?

• Which one screwed up?

• Or are they both really good quarterbacks, and we can finally put this discussion to bed?

And so on. And so on. And so on.

Bears Twitter and Commanders Twitter Chime In

To exactly nobody’s surprise, social media had plenty to say about the Caleb/Jayden conundrum in the hours after Washington’s Zane Gonzalez's perfectly executed doink ended the Bucs' 2024-25 season.

Some were very much on Team Caleb…

Yes, Jayden Daniels had a better rookie year than Caleb Williams. I don’t think anyone is arguing otherwise.

Yes, it’s also incredibly stupid to play the “did the #Bears pick the wrong QB” game this early. Player evaluations aren’t concrete after one season. Come on.

— Jacob Infante (@jacobinfante24) January 13, 2025

The Jayden talk getting ridiculous. He’s been good but Caleb’s ceiling is way higher. Would still take Caleb 100/100 times

— ♠️♦️ Michi ♥️♣️ (@Cinematoracle) January 13, 2025

Sorry national media. I still draft Caleb over Jayden Daniels. #DaBears

— JB (@CoffeeeNBears) January 13, 2025

…while others were all Jayden, all the time.

GOOD MORNING! Seeing a lot people act as if Jayden Daniels didn’t go to a 4 win team and turn them into a 12 win team and playoffs in first season. GM Ryan Poles was so cocky and confident in Caleb Williams ability he kept a trash head coach he didn’t upgrade the OL he truly…

— Chi BC2 (@BC2__) January 13, 2025

Jayden Daniels >>>>Caleb Williams

Leadership
Poise
Force multiplier
Arm talent
College competition
Escapability
Playmaking
Consistency

Also, Daniels is doing everything behind an average OL with a middling offensive weapons.

— Will Brooks (@ILLxWillBrooks) January 13, 2025

I'm happy with Caleb Williams. He was sabotaged by poor leadership and a crappy offensive line. Roll with him.

But Jayden Daniels looks like a boss....

— LaVelle E. Neal III (@LaVelleNeal) January 13, 2025

But there was a dissenting voice who doesn’t particularly appreciate either of them:

Everyone preferred Caleb Williams.
Everyone preferred Jayden Daniels.
Everyone preferred Drake Maye.
Everyone preferred Michael Penix Jr.
Everyone preferred JJ McCarthy.
Some even preferred Spencer Rattler.

Shoutout to Bo Nix for an elite season.
The future is bright in Denver.

— Sam Block (@theblockspot) January 12, 2025

—  Enjoy free coverage of the Bears from Chicago Bears on SI  —

More Chicago Bears News:

• Bears projected to land top head coaching candidate

• Early 2025 NFL mock drafts have Bears focusing on two prospects in first round

• Top young safety dubbed 'sensible target' for Bears in free agency

• Despite dysfunctional appearance, Bears still rank near top of head coach openings