Social media weighs in on Tom Brady-Patrick Mahomes GOAT debate after Super Bowl LIX

The Kansas City Chiefs have lost their second Super Bowl after being killed by the Philadelphia Eagles 40-22. That's the second time the Chiefs have gotten beat badly in the Super Bowl, with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Tom Brady throttling the Chiefs 31-9. That was Tom Brady's seventh Super Bowl ring, and ever since he retired, there's been more talk of a GOAT debate between Brady and Mahomes.

That GOAT debate got re-ignited on Sunday night after Mahomes played one of the worst games of his career. Those on social media noted that the game went a similar way to how the Bucs defeated the Chiefs in Super Bowl LV, and that with a Brady win over Mahomes and Super Bowl performances that were never as bad as this, the debate could be settled.

Here's what football fans on social media were saying after the game.

“When we beat them in Tampa…” @TomBrady music to our ears
— jill (@_jillbeckman) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady is 7-3 in Super Bowls.

Patrick Mahomes is 3-2 in Super Bowls.#Bucs are undefeated in Super Bowls. pic.twitter.com/hUzVP6gizV
— PewterReport 🏴‍☠️ (@PewterReport) February 10, 2025

Patrick Mahomes has bow been outscored 71-31 in Super Bowls where Tom Brady is present pic.twitter.com/bEMRpM0zRV
— NFL Memes (@NFL_Memes) February 10, 2025

Patriots, Tom Brady, and Bucs fans rn pic.twitter.com/U5bVz3CKnT
— C.O. (@Cris_Ocgd) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady looking down from the booth at the goat debate crumbling: pic.twitter.com/VSlyGhyoIQ
— Jovan (@jovan_deeb) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady looking for all the folks saying Mahomes is better pic.twitter.com/nPgMfE9sUn
— BettingPros (@BettingPros) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady watching Mahomes fumble the goat debate before his eyes: pic.twitter.com/myLy0xhA4h
— Colin (@IntroSpecktive) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady calling the rest of this game knowing Mahomes won’t be in the goat convo for a while pic.twitter.com/nTftSoqptN
— Nick Wright (@isnickwright) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady in the booth every time a Chiefs drive ends pic.twitter.com/ktMUDUQR5z
— NFL Memes (@NFL_Memes) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady in the booth right now watching Patrick Mahomes put up the worst first half in Super Bowl history pic.twitter.com/Y1hZDvLrdS
— SD 🦦 (@_sD98_) February 10, 2025

After that game, the Tom Brady-Patrick Mahomes debate is over.

There is only one GOAT pic.twitter.com/5CYepIrBjc
— Sophie Weller (@sophieewellerr) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady in the booth watching Mahomes have the worst performance by a quarterback in Super Bowl history like a Gotham villain.
— Ahmed/The Ears/IG: BigBizTheGod 🇸🇴 (@big_business_) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady never lost a Super Bowl by 22 (Mahomes in SB 55)

Brady never lost a Super Bowl by 18 (Mahomes tonight)

Brady never had three turnovers in a Super Bowl (Mahomes Tonight)

Brady never lost a Super Bowl to Mahomes (Mahomes lost to Brady in SB 55)

Tom Brady is the GOAT pic.twitter.com/wsy78vPCVH
— Tyler Englander (@TylerEnglander) February 10, 2025

Tom Brady is 7-3 in Super Bowls with a win over mahomes, with an afc championship win over him too. you can literally never compare mahomes to brady ever again. pic.twitter.com/1bIIGeddFC
— jason 🦥 🪐 (@spongebobsloth) February 10, 2025

Patrick Mahomes just can’t win playoff games when Tom Brady is in the building pic.twitter.com/JcqWKBnWne
— NFL Memes (@NFLHateMemes) February 10, 2025

Stick with BucsGameday for more coverage of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers throughout the 2024 season.

Follow BucsGameday on Twitter and Facebook

More Tampa Bay Buccaneers News

• Tampa Bay Buccaneers make splash by hiring Charlie Strong as defensive line coach

• NFL commissioner Roger Goodell reveals special relationship with Tom Brady

• Gerald McCoy addresses Buccaneers' biggest need going into 2025 season

• Chiefs' Patrick Mahomes reveals serious regret losing 2020 Super Bowl to Tom Brady, Buccaneers