All Panthers

2025 NFL draft 'nightmare scenario' for Panthers unlikely to go down

Thankfully, this Carolina Panthers nightmare scenario isn't likely to happen.
Carolina Panthers President of Football Operations/General Manager Dan Morgan talks to the media at the NFL Combine
Carolina Panthers President of Football Operations/General Manager Dan Morgan talks to the media at the NFL Combine | Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images

In this story:


The Carolina Panthers finished the 2024 season with a record of 5-12. That's not a great feeling, but if they look at how things went in the second half, there's a reason to believe this year can be better. Carolina started 1-7, but went 4-5 in their final five games. Most importantly, they saw growth from quarterback Bryce Young.

Heading into the 2025 season, they're looking to take the next step. While they need to continue building around Young, they must also fix their defense — which was a mess last year. That's why an impact defender is considered a must at No. 8 overall in the NFL draft.

RELATED: 2025 NFL mock draft: Panthers hit all the right notes with first 3 picks

Bleacher Report's Brad Gagnon knows that has to happen and says it would be a "nightmare scenario" if an early run on defenders left Carolina without an impact player at a position of need.

CAROLINA PANTHERS: Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham celebrates after sacking Minnesota quarterback Max Brosmer
CAROLINA PANTHERS: Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham celebrates after sacking Minnesota quarterback Max Brosmer | Eric Seals / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

"An early run on defensive players like Travis Hunter, Abdul Carter, Mason Graham, Jalon Walker, Malaki Starks and Will Johnson leaves a team in desperate need of a high-impact defender without any primo options on that side of the ball in the No. 8 spot." — Gagnon, Bleacher Report

The good news is that this is highly unlikely to happen. Gagnon names six players who could help the Panthers, and while technically those six could be selected, that would mean just one team ahead of them would have to select an offensive player. With Cam Ward expected to go first to the Tennessee Titans, that seems like a stretch.

Ward's selection would then mean the six players named by Gagnon would have to be selected consecutively.

That said, the Panthers are still going to have an impact defender available to them in Round 1.

- Enjoy more free Panthers coverage with Carolina Panthers on SI - 

Panthers projected to make blockbuster trade with 49ers in Round 1

NFL analyst mocks Steve Smith’s preferred WR1 to Carolina Panthers

Panthers expected to pick 71-TD developmental QB behind Bryce Young

Carolina Panthers among NFL teams using mock drafts in evaluations


Published
Randy Gurzi
RANDY GURZI

Randy Gurzi is a graduate of Arizona State and has focused on NFL coverage since 2014.