Bills Central

Bills' legend shockingly kept off NFL Top 25 all-time players list

See who ranked ahead of the NFL's all-time sacks leader, who was not even an honorable mention
Bills DE Bruce Smith rushes Miami quarterback Dan Marino on Oct. 9, 1994.
Bills DE Bruce Smith rushes Miami quarterback Dan Marino on Oct. 9, 1994. | Jamie Germano / USA TODAY NETWORK

When there are discussions about the best players in NFL history, not many Buffalo Bills come to mind. Despite there being one clear standout, he wasn't recognized on a list of the Top 25 NFL players of all time.

Bryan DeArdo of CBS Sports created his list of these players on Tuesday, and Bruce Smith, the NFL's all-time sacks leader who played for the Bills for 15 seasons, wasn't on that list, not even as an honorable mention.

To give some perspective on his list, DeArdo had NFL Hall of Famer and 1986 NFL MVP Lawrence Taylor as his seventh-best player in the league and two-time Defensive Player of the Year Reggie White as his eighth.

Bruce Smith
Orchard Park, NY, USA; FILE PHOTO; Bruce Smith of the Buffalo Bills in action against the New York Jets at Rich Stadium during the 1995 Season | Imagn Images / RVR Photos-Imagn Images

MORE: Bills' All-Time Top 10 Tight Ends: Two active players made the list

Although Taylor won Defensive Player of the Year three times in his career, including his rookie season, Smith still achieved the honor twice, so the questioning is validated.

DeArdo made his list based on several factors, including a player's legacy left on the league as a whole, championships won and ranking relative to his position. With these factors, a counterargument that Taylor and White best Smith in most of these categories makes sense as well.

TRENDING: Seven-year starter gives Bills' defense 'versatile' ace-in-hole for late October

Of course, that's not to take away from the other 23 players that made it onto DeArdo's list, but comparisons between these three historic edge rushers can go on and on if a list like this becomes more visible to the public.

Bruce Smith's number retirement
Sep 15, 2016; Orchard Park, NY, USA; Buffalo Bills former player Bruce Smith speaks as his number is retired in a ceremony during halftime against the New York Jets at New Era Field. The Jets beat the Bills 37-31. | Timothy T. Ludwig-Imagn Images

—  Enjoy free coverage of the Bills from Buffalo Bills on SI  —

More Buffalo Bills News:


Published
Owen Klein
OWEN KLEIN

Owen Klein has covered football, basketball and baseball for Penn State athletics as a broadcaster on local radio, including producing Penn State’s 2024 men’s basketball Big Ten Tournament games and calling Penn State football’s Whiteout vs. Washington in November 2024. He has internships with the Buffalo Bisons and CBS affiliate WIVB in Buffalo, NY, in the summer of 2025. He is a Penn State University broadcast journalism student at the Bellisario College of Communications majoring in broadcast journalism and is passionate about college and professional sports, the Pokémon Video Game Championships and the Buffalo Bills.

Share on XFollow Kleiner2003