Browns Digest

Browns Must Do Whatever It Takes To Trade Up For Right QB

If the Cleveland Browns identify their franchise quarterback in this class, they can't be afraid to trade up to get him at No. 1
Feb 25, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Cleveland Browns general manager Andrew Berry speaks during the NFL Scouting Combine at the Indiana Convention Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Feb 25, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Cleveland Browns general manager Andrew Berry speaks during the NFL Scouting Combine at the Indiana Convention Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images | Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

In this story:


The debate rages on over just how good the 2025 rookie quarterback class will be and whether or not the Cleveland Browns should be drafting one of them when they're on the clock with the second overall pick.

Questions over the viability of this year's signal callers are certainly valid. It's been a two-horse race between Colorado's Shedeur Sanders and Miami's Cam Ward for most of the offseason, and even those two prospects come with concerns.

That said, if there's one thing the NFL Combine revealed last week, it's that Cam Ward has separated himself from the rest of the class. He's undoubtedly the best QB in NFL circles. Now, it comes down to how willing teams at the top of the draft order are to draft him.

The Tennessee Titans hold all the leverage at the moment. They very well could just stay put and pull the trigger on Ward first overall. However, Tennessee finds itself in an abnormal situation where the general manager and head coach are on different timelines.

Entering year two, Brian Callahan theoretically is ready to find his quarterback of the future. But new GM Mike Borgonzi doesn't necessarily have to force the issue three months on the job.

That situation has raised plenty of questions about what the Titans will do with the first pick in the draft. Trading back seems very much in play and doing so would likely include a team looking to jump up and snag Ward as its franchise QB.

The Browns can't possibly stand by and let that happen.

If Cleveland identifies Ward as their quarterback of the future, they must be ready to do whatever it takes to trade up and get him at No. 1 overall.

Even though the Browns have a long history of drafting in the top 10 pretty regularly since the team returned in 1999, there's no guarantee that they're in this position again next spring.

The reality is they're drafting No. 2 right now, in 2025 and have a unique opportunity in front of them to turn this franchise around in a hurry by selecting the right QB. They can't waste that if they think they've identified that guy.

Maybe they haven't, or maybe they won't. Again, there is resounding consensus that this is a down year at the quarterback position. There also seems to be a growing belief that next year's class is going to be loaded with potential franchise signal callers.

Should the Browns decide to do anything other than draft a quarterback at No. 2 or trade up for one, it will reveal the organization's true thoughts on this year's class. But if Ward is it, you don't wait around for 2026 and all the unknowns that come with it.

In truth, Andrew Berry and Kevin Stefanski may not even have that kind of time. That duo's tenure is stained by the fallout of the Deshaun Watson trade. Finding an out feels like the only way they can truly redeem themselves.

It took a big swing to get into this mess, and it will likely take a big swing to get out of it. If that comes in the form of trading up from two to one to land a franchise-saving, and potentially job-saving, QB, you do it.

Yes, that move will come at a premium. The Browns and Titans would swap firsts this year. Cleveland would likely have to include this year's second as well or the two third-rounders Cleveland owns. A future first or second may even end up as part of the package.

If it nets a franchise quarterback, it'll all be worth it – even if giving up such a massive haul of picks gives Browns fans PTSD following the Watson deal.

Now it's up to Berry and company to decide if Ward is worth it. Or if they're okay taking their chances with Sanders, a different QB, or waiting altogether and using their stockpile of picks to fill out other needs on the roster.

Fear, however, is not an excuse.

Read More Cleveland Browns Coverage

MORE: Cleveland Browns Linked to QB Trade With Raiders

MORE: Browns Insider Reveals Hard Truth About 2025 QB Draft Class

MORE: The One Major Snag in Browns' Myles Garrett Trade Talks

MORE: Biggest Cleveland Browns Takeaways From the NFL Combine

MORE: Analyst Brutally Shreds Cleveland Browns GM


Published
Spencer German
SPENCER GERMAN

Spencer German is a contributor to the Northeast Ohio cluster of sites, including Cavs Insider, Cleveland Baseball Insider and most notably Browns Digest. He also works as a fill-in host on Cleveland Sports Radio, 92.3 The Fan, one of the Browns radio affiliate stations in Cleveland. Despite being a Cleveland transplant, Spencer has enjoyed making Northeast Ohio home ever since he attended college locally at John Carroll University, where he graduated in 2013.

Share on XFollow @Spencito_