Cowboys Country

Did the Cowboys do enough to fix their massive flaw on defense?

The Dallas Cowboys' biggest weakness on defense in 2024 could be their biggest weakness in 2025.
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith and Detroit Lions center Frank Ragnow battle during the second quarter.
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith and Detroit Lions center Frank Ragnow battle during the second quarter. | Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

It's a tale as old as time. The Dallas Cowboys once again find themselves preparing for a new season with one glaring need—a run-stuffing nose tackle.

Dallas should be applauded for making the 1-tech a priority in 2023 when they used their first-round pick on Michigan's Mazi Smith. The problem is that Smith has yet to prove himself worthy of his draft status, and the Cowboys are refusing to do much to challenge him.

MORE: Versatile Cowboys defensive back hopes to fill Jourdan Lewis void

That was the topic of a recent mailbag on the team's official website, with beat writers agreeing the front office didn't do enough. Mickey Spagnola was at least complimentary of Smith, saying he improved in 2024. Still, he's not confident in the position, even with the addition of Jay Toia.

UCLA Bruins defensive lineman Jay Toia during the second quarter against the Fresno State Bulldogs at Rose Bowl.
UCLA Bruins defensive lineman Jay Toia during the second quarter against the Fresno State Bulldogs at Rose Bowl. | Robert Hanashiro-Imagn Images

”They are relying heavily on Mazi Smith taking the next step as a 1-tech defensive tackle, and Mazi did improve last year off his rookie season. They did draft two defensive tackles in the seventh round, one of those the 342-pound Jay Toia from UCLA.” — Spagnola

Tommy Yarrish was slightly more blunt with his answer, saying Smith is a "glaring question mark," while adding the younger options have their own concerns.

MORE: Former Dallas Cowboys lineman rips Aaron Rodgers amid Steelers saga

”Personally, I don't think so. Mazi Smith still has a glaring question mark in front of him, and the depth behind him isn't enough to convince me that the Cowboys are set at that position to stop the run at a consistent rate. There's so much unknown in the room with younger guys who either don't have any playing time or don't have enough quality reps, so it would be a spot that wouldn't shock me at all if the Cowboys stick to their 24/7, 365 player acquisition model to find a veteran body to add depth, or maybe a starting quality player.” — Yarrish

Both Yarrish and Spagnola believe the Cowboys will be looking for another option, whether through free agency or a trade. Whatever they do, Dallas has to figure out a way to stop the run, or this could be another frustrating campaign.

Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith after the game against the San Francisco 49ers at Levi's Stadium.
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith after the game against the San Francisco 49ers at Levi's Stadium. | Kyle Terada-Imagn Images

— Enjoy free coverage of the Cowboys from Dallas Cowboys on SI 

Micah Parsons vows to be in attendance for Dallas Cowboys minicamp

Cowboys EVP Stephen Jones reveals if team has plans to make more offseason moves

Should Dallas Cowboys panic about Micah Parsons contract drama?

Dallas Cowboys 2024 starter named 'expendable' trade candidate

PHOTOS: Meet Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader Rookie Abby Summers


Published
Randy Gurzi
RANDY GURZI

Randy Gurzi is a graduate of Arizona State and has focused on NFL coverage since 2014.