Mike McCarthy praised by Cowboys players before contract talk breakdown

The NFLPA is in agreement when it comes to the staggering grading of Dallas Cowboys' former head coach.

Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy on the sidelines against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field. / Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

The Dallas Cowboys disrupted the NFL news cycle when the front office and Mike McCarthy could not come to terms on a contract extension in January.

Since then, the Cowboys have hired Brian Schottenheimer as the head coach and assembled an experienced, knowledgeable, and skilled coaching staff.

MORE: Cowboys at least do one thing right per NFLPA annual report card

In his five seasons with the Cowboys, McCarthy led the team to three playoff berths and three straight 12-5 seasons, earning the respect and admiration of players on both offense and defense.

Despite a 7-10 record this season, his strong relationships with players on the Cowboys roster were reflected in his head coaching grade, released today by the NFLPA.

Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott talks to head coach Mike McCarthy before the game against the Washington Commanders / Tim Heitman-Imagn Images

Mike McCarthy received an A grade, which is primarily based on his efficiency with players' time and how receptive they were to feedback from the locker room regarding the team's needs.

MORE: NFL coaching legend endorses Cowboys' HC Brian Schottenheimer

He has often been regarded as a players' coach due to his strong relationships, though this has sometimes worked to a fault.

Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy reacts after a play against the Cincinnati Bengals. / Tim Heitman-Imagn Images

Cowboys Hall of Fame wide receiver Michael Irvin criticized McCarthy's decision not to force the team to stay together the night before a home game, suggesting that McCarthy's leniency may have led to a lack of focus leading up to critical games.

There is certainly a point to be made that McCarthy's leniency with the team's players may have been to a fault. While he kept the team in good spirits, he may have sacrificed keeping their focus on what matters most in football: winning games.

— Enjoy free coverage of the Cowboys from Dallas Cowboys on SI —

3 quarterbacks Cowboys could target on Day 3 of the 2025 NFL Draft

Key NFL Scouting Combine dates Cowboys fans need to know

Stephen Jones reveals Dallas Cowboys' plan for NFL free agency

Should Cowboys reunite with former star receiver in free agency?

One free agent the Cowboys should consider to bolster secondary

Meet Sophy Laufer: Star of Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader Netflix docuseries