Perhaps the Dallas Cowboys aren’t as great in the draft as we thought

The Dallas Cowboys seem to have a major flaw in their scouting.

Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones on the sidelines before the game against the New York Giants. | Raymond Carlin III-Imagn Images

The Dallas Cowboys are often praised for their work in the NFL draft, and for good reason.

They boast a collection of homegrown talent led by Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and Tyler Smith. They’ve also recently said goodbye to multiple future Hall of Fame offensive linemen they drafted and developed, including Tyron Smith and Zack Martin.

MORE: Jadeveon Clowney gets first chance to impress Dallas Cowboys in Week 4 vs Packers

As impressive as all that is, the Cowboys might be getting more credit than they deserve. While they excel at drafting offensive players, Zach Wolchuk of 105.3 The Fan just pointed out how bad they’ve been at selecting defensive players.

"They have 25 defensive picks since 2021, 15 of those picks are no longer on the team,” Wolchuk said.

How did the #DallasCowboys defense get so bad?@ZachWolchuk: "They have 25 defensive picks since 2021, 15 of those picks are no longer on the team."

Listen to the entire discussion with @BryanBroaddus, @gavindawson and @EricChiofalo in the comments.⤵️ pic.twitter.com/9TReyLr8qk

— 105.3 The FAN (@1053thefan) September 22, 2025

He states that 2025 isn’t included before going through the list. Marshawn Kneeland and Marist Liufau from the 2024 class have shown flashes but aren’t consistent. Then there’s Mazi Smith, Sam Williams, and Damone Clark, who Wolchuk says haven’t been good.

Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith at training camp at the River Ridge Fields. | Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

As for some of the good selections, there’s DeMarvion Overshown and DaRon Bland, although both have struggled with injuries. Trevon Diggs was also thrown into the injury mix.

The one defensive pick labeled the most consistent is Osa Odighizuwa, but even he hasn’t made a difference this season.

It’s actually a disturbing trend and helps explain how this defense has become so bad after trading away their biggest draft hit on that side of the ball, Micah Parsons.

Dallas Cowboys defensive end Micah Parsons at training camp at the River Ridge Fields. | Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

— Enjoy free coverage of the Cowboys from Dallas Cowboys on SI —

3 winners & 4 losers from Cowboys' unbelievable loss to Bears in Week 3

3 takeaways from Dallas Cowboys' deflating loss vs. Bears

NFL Power Rankings Roundup: Dallas Cowboys free fall begins after dreadful loss

Cowboys WR George Pickens goes viral for sideline meltdown in loss to Bears

Dallas Cowboys must find a way to get more touches for electric WR

PHOTOS: Meet Kleine Powell, star of Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader Netflix doc